Cards are fast and familiar, and they cost around 3% of every payment. On a big job that is real money. A bank payment (ACH) costs a fraction of that, but it works differently: it takes days to clear, it can fail, and some customers have never used it. This guide puts numbers on both, explains the waiting and the risks, and shows when to steer customers to a bank payment.
Card vs bank at a glance
| Card | Bank (ACH debit) | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical fee | 2.9% + 30 cents | 0.8%, never more than $5 |
| Extra bank-account check | None | $1.50 when the customer's bank is checked instantly |
| When you see the money | Usually a couple of business days | About 4 business days |
| Can it fail after you think it worked? | Rarely, but customers can dispute | Yes: insufficient funds, bad account details |
| Failed payment fee | None | $4.00 on Stripe |
| Dispute fee | $15.00 on Stripe | $15.00 on Stripe |
| Customer dispute window | Months, through the card network | Up to 60 days on a personal account |
| Who it suits | Small bills, speed, convenience | Large bills, deposits, customers who dislike cards |
Sources for the bank numbers: Stripe's local payment methods pricing and ACH Direct Debit documentation.
A $4,000 job paid both ways
A deck, rails and fence for $4,000, and the customer pays the whole balance.
You absorb the fee:
| Card | Bank | |
|---|---|---|
| Invoice | $4,000.00 | $4,000.00 |
| Processing fee | $116.30 (2.9% = $116.00, plus $0.30) | $5.00 (0.8% would be $32.00, but the cap is $5) |
| Bank account check | none | $1.50, billed by Stripe separately at month end |
| You keep | $3,883.70 | $3,993.50 |
The difference is $109.80 on one job. If you take five jobs this size a month on cards, that is about $550 a month, or $6,600 a year in fees you could have avoided.
You pass the fee to the customer (where that is allowed; see below). The fee has to be grossed up so the processor's cut of the fee itself is covered:
| Card | Bank | |
|---|---|---|
| Fee added | $119.77 | $6.50 |
| Customer pays | $4,119.77 | $4,006.50 |
| Processor keeps | $119.77 | $6.50 ($5.00 plus the $1.50 check) |
| You receive | $4,000.00 | $4,000.00 |
The bank fee for any bill over $625 is a flat $6.50 to the customer at Stripe's prices. The card fee keeps growing with the bill.
How the fee scales
| Bill | Card fee (2.9% + 30 cents) | Bank fee (0.8%, max $5) |
|---|---|---|
| $250 | $7.55 | $2.00 |
| $625 | $18.43 | $5.00 |
| $1,500 | $43.80 | $5.00 |
| $4,000 | $116.30 | $5.00 |
| $12,000 | $348.30 | $5.00 |
Add $1.50 to the bank column for the account check. Even on a $250 bill, bank costs $3.50 against $7.55 for a card. On a $12,000 job, the difference is about $342 in your favor.
Our card fee calculator does the grossed-up math for card payments, and the card fee guide covers the rules and the 3% cap: can contractors charge a credit card fee.
Why bank payments show pending
A card payment is approved or declined on the spot. A bank (ACH) debit is different. The request goes through the banking network, and the answer can take days. Stripe says an ACH debit can take up to 4 business days to confirm success or failure.
So the money is on its way, but it is not yours yet, and not safe to count:
- The job is not "paid" until it clears. Do not release a finished project, a key or a warranty on the day the customer taps pay.
- Plan cash around the delay. If you need money by Friday, ask for the bank payment by the Monday before, or take a card.
- Remind a customer once it clears, not before. A customer who has paid should not get a "past due" notice.
Failed and returned payments
A bank payment can fail after it looks fine. The usual reasons:
- Insufficient funds. The most common.
- Wrong account or routing number.
- The account is closed or blocked from debits.
- The customer disputes it with their bank. For a personal account this can happen up to 60 days after the debit. After a dispute, you cannot appeal the decision, and you need to resolve it with the customer directly.
If a payment fails after you have been credited, Stripe takes the money back and charges a $4.00 failure fee. In rare cases the failure comes after the payment seemed to succeed.
What to do:
- Contact the customer the same day, by phone. Keep it neutral: "Your bank payment didn't go through. Can we try another way?"
- Offer a card or a different account.
- Do not hand over anything (final walkthrough sign-off, a warranty document) until it is paid.
- Ask for the new payment up front, not with a promise to pay again later.
- If it keeps happening, move to card or check for that customer.
For a customer who simply isn't paying, see what to do when a customer won't pay.
Passing the bank fee on
You can absorb the bank fee, pass it on, or give a small discount for paying by bank. A few points:
- The bank fee is tiny. On bills over $625 it is $6.50 at Stripe's prices, so many contractors absorb it and use the saving as their reason to ask for bank payments.
- Card rules do not apply to bank debits. Visa's 3% cap and the card network surcharge rules cover cards. A bank transfer is not a card. State consumer laws may still require clear disclosure, so tell the customer the fee before they pay and show it as its own line. Check your state's rules.
- The simplest approach: price in the card cost and offer a discount for paying by bank. It avoids most surcharge rules. See can contractors charge a credit card fee for how a cash discount differs from a surcharge.
Sample wording:
We accept cards, bank transfer, check and cash. Card payments carry a processing fee. Bank transfers cost much less to process, so there is a small [or no] fee for paying that way.
When to steer customers to bank
- Large invoices. The bigger the bill, the more a card costs. Over about $1,500, the gap is real money.
- Deposits on big jobs, if the start date is far enough away to wait for it to clear. See deposits for contractors.
- Property managers, HOAs and businesses, who often prefer to pay from a bank account.
- Customers who ask for a lower price, where a bank payment is a fair way to give them a break on the fee, not on your work.
Where bank is a poor fit:
- Small bills, where the $1.50 check is a big share of the fee.
- Jobs where cash arrives late and you cannot wait four days, like paying for materials.
- Customers who don't have an account they can log into, or who are nervous about linking one.
How to ask:
The fastest way for us is to pay from your bank account. It takes a few days to clear and costs us less, so we keep our prices lower. You can pick it on the payment page. Of course, card works too.
Checks, Zelle and cash
- Checks. No processing fee, but it can bounce, and you wait for it to clear. Deposit promptly. If a check bounces, you are back to collecting. Keep the customer's contact information on file.
- Zelle and similar apps. Quick and cheap, but a payment sent to the wrong person cannot easily be pulled back, and scammers use these apps. Match names to your customer and record each one by hand.
- Cash. No fee, but handle it carefully. Count it with the customer, give a receipt, and deposit it. Write down every cash payment so your books match.
Whatever the method, record every payment against the invoice, the same day.
How Chalk helps
This part is about our software. Skip it if you only want the fee advice.
- A "Pay from my bank" option. Once you connect Stripe, turn on bank payments under Settings > Connectors > Payments. Stripe may review the request first. Customers see Pay by card, Pay from my bank, Check and Cash on their invoice, with each online option showing its fee in dollars or "No fee". See take card and bank payments.
- You choose who pays the fee. Customer pays the bank fee is a separate switch from the card one, and it is off until you turn it on. When it is on, the bank fee is 0.8% (never more than $5) plus the $1.50 check, grossed up, which is never more than $6.50. See pass card and bank fees to customers.
- Pending is clear. A bank payment shows as Payment pending on the invoice. While it is pending, automatic reminders and the late fee wait. If it fails, the invoice is owed again and the reminders pick up. The owner has Check with the bank again and Mark as did not go through. See why a bank payment shows as pending.
- Payouts. The owner sees an estimate on each online payment: about two business days for cards and about four for bank payments.
- Cash and checks are recorded by hand. See record cash and check payments and mark a check as bounced.
Chalk takes no cut of the job. The fees above go to the payment processor.
Sources
- Stripe, Local payment methods pricing: ACH Direct Debit 0.8% with a $5.00 cap, $4.00 for failed payments, $15.00 for disputes, $1.50 for instant bank account verification
- Stripe, ACH Direct Debit documentation: settlement and confirmation up to 4 business days, return reasons, and the 60 day dispute window on personal accounts
- The card figures use the common 2.9% + 30 cents rate as an example. Check your processor statement for your own rate.