Growth and leads

Are paid lead sites worth it for contractors?

How Thumbtack, Angi, Google Local Services Ads, Yelp and Nextdoor charge, and how to judge any of them with your own cost per job won.

Adrian GluchowskiOwner of Superior Stain Solutions, builder of ChalkLast reviewed 12 min read

On this page

Paid lead sites can fill a calendar fast, or cost more than they bring in if you don't track them. Whether one is worth it depends on four numbers from your own business: what a lead costs, how many of those people you actually reach, how many of those hire you, and what a job earns you.

This guide shows how the main sites charge, based on their own help pages as of October 2026, then gives you the math, a way to test one for 60 to 90 days, and when to stop.

The short answer

A lead site is worth it when your cost per job won is comfortably below the gross profit a job earns you, after counting your time. It can be true in one trade, season or zip code and false in another. You only know by tracking it.

Three things decide most of it:

  • How the site shares the customer. On some sites a customer can contact several pros. On others you pay for a click or an impression, not a person.
  • How fast you answer. When a customer is talking to several pros, the first useful reply has the edge.
  • Your close rate. A shop that books 1 in 3 people it talks to can afford leads that a shop booking 1 in 8 cannot.

How each site charges

Checked on each company's own pages in October 2026. Programs change often, so read the current terms before you sign up.

SiteHow you payOne business or several?Refunds or credits they publishSource
ThumbtackPer lead, at a price you set. Opportunities: you reach out, and pay only if they respond.Up to five pros in the first four hours, more after.Automatic refund if the customer replies to no pro in 72 hours, with conditions. Other requests within 45 days.Thumbtack Help
Angi (and HomeAdvisor)Per lead or subscription. Charged when you and the homeowner both show interest.No more than five pros per request.Credits for listed reasons on leads under 45 days old, after review. None on annual subscriptions.Angi Help Center
Google Local Services AdsPer lead: a call, message, voicemail or booking to your business.A customer contacting you. Not called exclusive.Low-quality leads may be credited automatically.Google Ads Help
Yelp AdsPer click, within your budget.Clicks, not leads. Quote requests can go to several businesses.Says it filters invalid clicks.Yelp for Business
NextdoorAds: per impression, or a monthly subscription. Opportunity Alerts: monthly, cancel anytime.Alerts point to a neighbor's post asking for a pro. Nextdoor doesn't say how many businesses get the same alert.Not covered on the pages we read.Nextdoor Help

Thumbtack

  • You pay for leads where the customer contacted you, at a lead price you set for each service, out of a weekly budget you choose. Thumbtack says how fast you respond is one of the things that affects how many leads you get.
  • Limited competition. Thumbtack says it limits a customer to five pros in the first four hours, that customers usually contact fewer, and that they can contact more after four hours. See Quality Commitment. Thumbtack also says each lead's insights show whether the customer is replying to other pros.
  • Fair Shot Refunds are automatic only when you accept the lead and reply through Thumbtack within four business hours (8 AM to 8 PM your time), don't share your own phone or email before the customer's first reply, and the customer replies to no pro within 72 hours. See Fair Shot Refund policy.
  • No refund when the customer hires someone else, per the refund policy. Refunds go to your Thumbtack balance by default. You can ask for a refund to your card within 10 business days of approval.

Angi and HomeAdvisor

HomeAdvisor is one of Angi Inc.'s brands. Its 2025 annual report lists Angi, Angie's List and HomeAdvisor. The rules below come from Angi's help center for pros, so if you signed up through HomeAdvisor, check that they match your account.

  • How many pros. Angi says it will match each project request with "no more than five pros," and the same for Opportunities.
  • When you pay. Lead fees vary by task, location and demand. You are charged when you and the homeowner have both shown interest, "whether or not you open or respond to" the lead. On a subscription, you are charged monthly.
  • Credits. Angi lists five reasons: invalid contact info, wrong location, a service you don't offer, a duplicate within 45 days, or a charge while your leads were paused. The lead must be under 45 days old, and you should have tried to call within 24 hours. Credits go toward future leads and expire after six months. Annual subscriptions get no credits.
  • Not credited: a homeowner who never answers, hires another pro first, drops the project, is collecting quotes, or turns down your quote. Angi says these cases are accounted for in its lead pricing.

Google Local Services Ads

  • What counts as a lead. A call you answer or return, a missed call during business hours where the caller stays on more than 20 seconds, a text or email, a voicemail, or a booking request. Prices vary by location, job type, lead type and bidding mode, and leads Google judges invalid or low quality at first contact are not charged.
  • Exclusive or not. Every lead is a customer who contacted your business. Google's page does not use the word exclusive, and says message lead prices consider "whether the customer has contacted other Local Services advertisers." So don't assume you are the only call.
  • Credits. Google says it reassesses charged leads and may credit low-quality ones automatically, and you can rate a lead to give feedback. It no longer credits "job type not serviced" or "geo not serviced" leads, so keep your service area and job types tight.
  • Speed counts. Google says a consistently fast response time could improve your ad's ranking.

Yelp

  • Yelp Ads charge per click. Your budget is a daily average, and Yelp says you never go over your monthly maximum. Self-serve ads have no term contract and can be cancelled anytime, per the Yelp Ads page. Yelp says it filters invalid clicks and does not bill for clicks in rapid succession from the same user.
  • Quote requests can go to several businesses. Yelp's help for customers says that after describing a project, a customer may choose to send the request to additional businesses "to receive competing quotes." See How do I message a business or request a quote?

Nextdoor

  • Ads. Pay as You Go bills you for impressions after they run. A monthly subscription charges your daily budget times 30 upfront, at a 10% discount, and renews until you cancel.
  • Opportunity Alerts is a separate paid subscription that alerts you when a neighbor posts asking for a service you offer, so you can comment or message them. Nextdoor's product page doesn't list a price, so check the price shown when you sign up. More in Nextdoor and Facebook groups.

The math: cost per job won

The price per lead is not the number that matters. This is:

Cost per job won = Price per lead / Contact rate / Close rate
  • Contact rate: of the leads you paid for, the share you actually spoke with.
  • Close rate: of the people you spoke with, the share who hired you.

Then compare it with what a job earns:

Gross profit per job = Average job price x Gross margin

A worked example. These numbers are made up to show the math. Use your own.

ItemNumber
Price per lead$45
Leads in a month20, so $900 spent
People you reached12 (a 60% contact rate)
Jobs won3 (a 25% close rate)
Average job$1,000 at a 40% gross margin, so $400 gross profit

Cash only: $45 / 0.60 / 0.25 = $300 per job won. Check: $900 / 3 jobs = $300. Each job earns $400, so $100 is left per job, or $300 for the month.

Now count your time. Say each person you reach takes an hour between calls and an estimate visit, and your hour is worth $40 (see how to figure your hourly rate). That is 12 hours, or $480, which is $160 per job won. The real cost is $300 + $160 = $460 per job, against $400 earned. You lost $60 a job, $180 for the month.

Now answer faster. Same price and close rate, but you reach 16 of the 20 (80%). You win 4 jobs. Cash per job: $45 / 0.80 / 0.25 = $225. Time: 16 hours, $640, or $160 per job. Total: $385 per job, against $400. Now you made $15 a job, $60 for the month. Check: 4 x $400 = $1,600, minus $900 and $640, is $60.

Your break-even lead price at the first example's numbers: $400 x 0.60 x 0.25 = $60 of gross profit per lead, minus $24 of your time per lead (0.60 x $40). So $36 is the most you can pay per lead and break even.

Two cautions. A customer who books you every year is worth more than one job, so check how many customers from a site come back before you write it off. And refunds and credits lower your real spend, so use what you paid after them.

Why speed and follow-up matter more on shared leads

When a customer can contact up to five pros, the first useful reply has the edge. Thumbtack's refund policy notes that many customers hire "the quickest and most helpful pro." Angi says, "The faster you respond, the better your chance of winning the job."

  1. Get a loud alert for every new lead, and answer within minutes when you can. Speed to lead has a five-minute setup and first-reply scripts.
  2. Call, then text. If they don't pick up, leave a short voicemail and send a text with your name and a question about the job.
  3. Follow up more than once. A customer collecting quotes is busy, not gone. Chase on day 2 and day 5, then once more a week later. See how to follow up on estimates.
  4. Know each site's clock. Thumbtack's automatic refund needs a reply within four business hours. Angi's credits expect a call attempt within 24 hours.

How to test a lead site for 60 to 90 days

  1. Set a cap before you start, for example $1,000 over 90 days, and stick to it.
  2. Tighten your settings to the services, job sizes and zip codes you want. Google, for one, no longer credits leads outside them.
  3. Log every lead the day it arrives: date, site, price, whether you reached them, estimate booked, won or lost, and the job amount.
  4. Request credits the same week for anything that fits the site's published reasons.
  5. At 30 days, check contact rate. If you reach fewer than half, fix your reply speed before you judge the site.
  6. At 60 to 90 days, work out cost per job won, including your time, and compare it to your gross profit per job.
  7. Decide: keep it, change the settings or price and test again, or stop.

Aim for 30 or more leads. Ten is too few to tell luck from a pattern.

Signs it isn't working, and when to stop

  • Cost per job won is above your gross profit per job after two full months, even with fast replies.
  • You reach fewer than half the people you pay for, even when you answer within minutes.
  • Most leads are outside your area or services after you have tightened your settings.
  • You can't tell what you spent. Save your billing history each month.
  • You are dropping lower-cost work (referrals, repeat customers, your Google profile) to chase paid leads.
  • A contract term you haven't read. Read the cancellation and credit terms before you sign anything annual.

Stopping is not a failure. You can test again next season with better numbers.

Cheaper channels that work alongside or instead

Paid leads work best on top of channels you own, which keep paying after you stop spending:

A good customer from a lead site can become a referral and a repeat customer too. The full channel map is in How to get more customers for a service business.

How Chalk helps

This part is about our software. Skip it if you only want the advice.

  • A source on every lead. Add each site (for example "Thumbtack" or "Angi") to your lead sources under Settings > Lists in Lead funnel. When you add a lead by hand with New lead on the Funnel, pick it under How did they find us?.
  • Win rate by source. Reports > Marketing shows, for the last 90 days, leads, won jobs, win rate and won value for each source. Win rate there is won jobs out of all leads, so it already includes the people you never reached. Your cost per job won for a site is what you spent there divided by its won jobs. See Reports.
  • Getting leads in. Chalk does not pull leads from Thumbtack, Angi, Google Local Services Ads, Yelp or Nextdoor, and has no direct connection to them. Type leads in with New lead, or have a tool like Zapier post them to Lead ingest with the site's name in the source field. See Send leads in with Zapier or a webhook. Angi's help center describes sending your leads to a Zapier webhook. We have not tested that route with a live Angi account. For other sites, ask whether they can send leads to a webhook.
  • Speed and follow-up. A lead that comes in through Lead ingest gives an alert in the app and texts the owner once texting is set up. The Funnel flags a new lead nobody has called, and Log a call sets the next chase date. When a lead goes nowhere, mark it lost with a reason such as No response. See Work your leads on the Funnel.
  • Limits. Chalk doesn't know what you paid a site, so keep your spend and credits in your own sheet and divide by won jobs. It doesn't report reply time in minutes either.

FAQ

Is Thumbtack worth it for contractors? When your cost per job won, including your time, is below your gross profit per job. Thumbtack lets you set your lead price, so you can test at a price your numbers support.

Is Angi worth it? Same test. Angi says a request goes to no more than five pros, so reply speed and close rate matter. Check the credit rules and contract length first.

Are Google Local Services Ads leads exclusive? Each lead is a customer contacting your business directly. Google does not call them exclusive, and a customer can contact other advertisers too.

Can I get my money back if the customer never answers? Thumbtack refunds automatically if the customer replies to no pro within 72 hours and you met its conditions. Angi does not credit a homeowner who doesn't answer, and says that case is built into its lead prices. Google may credit leads it judges low quality.

How long should I test a lead site? 60 to 90 days, with a cap set in advance and at least 30 leads.

Sources

All checked October 11, 2026. Terms change, so check the current page.

Thumbtack, Angi, HomeAdvisor, Google, Yelp and Nextdoor are trademarks of their owners. Chalk is not affiliated with or endorsed by any of them.