On Nextdoor and in local Facebook groups, neighbors ask each other "who do you use for gutters?" all day. A contractor who shows up well in those threads gets calls from people who are ready to hire. A contractor who shows up badly gets muted, banned or ignored.
This guide covers what is free and what is paid, how to build a page that gets recommended, how to answer "who do you recommend?" posts without being the person everybody rolls their eyes at, and how to deal with the price shoppers these places attract. Rules on both platforms change often, so the rules sections link to the platform's own pages.
Claim the free Nextdoor page
Start with the free Business Page. Nextdoor says claiming it and posting from it are free. You need to be an owner, employee or other authorized representative of the business, and some businesses are asked for business documents to verify.
A complete page has:
- Your business name, the same one as on your truck and your Google profile.
- A cover photo and a logo.
- A phone number you answer.
- The area you serve and what you do, in plain words.
- A handful of real photos of finished work.
The page is what a neighbor sees when someone tags you or when they search. A page with nothing on it tells them you are not serious.
The rule that matters most. In August 2026 Nextdoor announced that promoting a business, service or paid opportunity must be done from a free Business Page, not a personal neighbor account. That covers posts and comments in the main feed, and unsolicited direct messages. Neighbors can still recommend businesses they like from their own accounts. Posts that break the rule stay up but reach fewer neighbors, and the poster gets a notice. Nextdoor says this does not apply to Groups, and that Opportunity Alerts and ads are not affected.
What that means for you: do not post "I do roof cleaning, call me" from your personal profile. Use the business page.
Get Faves from real customers
A Fave is Nextdoor's version of a vouch. Nextdoor says each one is tied to a verified neighbor. Nextdoor also says that the more Faves you earn, the more likely you are to show in its search, but that is the company's own claim. Written recommendations are separate from Faves.
How to collect them, from Nextdoor's own guide:
- Find your page link under the Page tab.
- Send it to customers after a job, with a thank-you. People need to sign in or create a free account to leave one.
- Add the link to your website, your emails and your invoices.
- Thank everyone who recommends you, from your page.
Here is a text you can copy for a customer who just paid and said they were happy:
Hi Dana, thanks again for having us out. If you are on Nextdoor and have a minute, a Fave or a short recommendation helps neighbors find us: [link]. No pressure at all, and thank you either way.
Keep it honest. Ask people who were happy, ask after the job, and do not pay for recommendations or offer a discount for one. That also protects you with Google, where offering payment or discounts for reviews is against the rules. I have not found a Nextdoor page that spells out its own rule on incentives. US law already covers part of it: the FTC says a recommendation given in return for a reward has to say so, and its 2024 rule on reviews bans rewards that depend on the review being positive. The simple rule is to ask, and not to pay.
Facebook groups: read the rules first
Local Facebook groups (your town's community group, a neighborhood group, a "moms of [town]" group) work like Nextdoor with more mood swings. Each group's admins write their own rules, and breaking them gets you removed.
Before you post anything:
- Read the rules and pinned posts. Many groups ban self-promotion outright, or only allow it on one day a week, or only in a thread the admins create.
- Watch for a week. See who gets recommended, how people ask, and what the admins delete.
- Join as a person, not a salesman. Answer questions you know the answer to, even when they have nothing to do with your trade. People remember the person who helped.
Meta's Spam standard bans posting the same content at very high frequencies, and also bans giving rewards in exchange for engagement, such as "like my page to win $500." If a group's admins see you pasting the same ad in ten groups, expect to be removed from all of them.
A Facebook Page for your business is free. It gives you a home for photos, a link for your request form and something for people to tag when they recommend you.
Answering "who do you recommend?" posts
This is the highest-value moment on either platform. Someone asks for a painter, and fifteen people reply. The best reply is a customer who tags you. The second-best is you, done right.
If a customer tags you or recommends you: reply fast and thank them.
Thank you, Dana, that means a lot! [Name], happy to look at your project. You can call or text me at (555) 555-0100 or send photos here: [request form link].
If you reply yourself: keep it short, factual and open about who you are. Do not claim to be a neighbor who "heard good things."
Hi [Name], I'm Sam with Hill Country Painting. We do exterior and interior painting around Maplewood and have been at it for 8 years. Happy to give you a free estimate. Text me photos at (555) 555-0100 or use this form: [link]. If we are not the right fit, I can point you to someone who is.
What to avoid:
- Replying to every post in the group. Pick the ones that fit your trade and your area.
- Pasting the same reply every time. People notice.
- Dropping a price in a public thread that you cannot hold to. A private reply gives you room to ask questions.
- Attacking other contractors or a bad review. Even if you are right, you lose.
- Arguing with a bad review in public. Reply once, politely, with your phone number, and take it offline.
On Nextdoor, I could not confirm from public pages whether a free Business Page can reply to a neighbor's request, or whether that needs a paid Opportunity Alerts subscription. Check your own page. If you cannot reply, the work falls to your customers who recommend you, and to the people who see your page. That is another reason to ask for Faves.
Photos and before-and-afters
Nobody believes a paragraph about quality. A photo does the job in one second.
- Take before and after shots from the same spot, in the same light. A phone is fine. Hold it level, and clean the lens.
- Show a complete project, not close-ups of one board.
- Ask the customer before you post their house, and leave off the street number.
- One strong photo per post with a short caption: "Cedar fence, stained in two days. 80 feet. Maplewood."
- Do not use photos from other contractors or stock. It gets spotted, and in a neighborhood group everybody knows everybody.
Paid ads on either: when to test
Both platforms sell ads. On Nextdoor, you can run ads and you can pay for Opportunity Alerts. They are different products, and you are not enrolled in one by buying the other.
- Opportunity Alerts notifies service businesses when neighbors post requests in your categories. Nextdoor says pricing varies by service category, area and number of categories, and shows the final price before you subscribe. Read the billing and cancellation terms before you sign up, and check whether you can leave at any time.
- Ads can reach neighbors farther out than free posts. Nextdoor lets you set a daily budget, and its help pages describe both pay-as-you-go and a monthly subscription. Check the billing screen before you commit.
My rule for testing paid anything: set a cap, run it for 60 to 90 days, and judge it by cost per job won, not by clicks. The formula is in How to get more customers for a service business, and how other paid lead sites charge is in Are paid lead sites worth it?. Start only after the free basics are working and you reply to leads within minutes. Paying for traffic you answer slowly is the most common way to waste money here.
Filtering price shoppers
Neighborhood threads attract people comparing prices. That is fine, if you handle it quickly and do not drive out for every one.
1. Ask for photos before you promise anything. A photo request is a polite filter, because people who are only collecting numbers rarely send them.
Happy to help. Could you send two or three photos of the area and the approximate size? I can give you a close price from those, and if the job needs a visit I will tell you.
2. Give a range, not a surprise. If you can say "most decks like that run $X to $Y", say it. It saves you both time. Jobs that fit the range come to you. Those that don't, drop out without you driving anywhere.
3. Have a minimum. If a job under $X doesn't pay for the trip, say so up front: "My minimum is $150." See should contractors charge for estimates for ways to charge for a trip.
4. Don't race. If someone says "the other guy said $200," you can say:
That sounds like a fair price for a basic job. We do [the prep, the product, the cleanup], which is why we are higher. If price is the main thing, they may be the right fit for you.
You will lose some jobs that way. You will also keep the margin on the ones you win. For word-for-word replies to price pushback, see What to say when a customer says your price is too high.
5. Reply fast. The first reply wins more than the cheapest. See Speed to lead.
How Chalk helps
This part is about our software. Skip it if you only want the advice.
- A request form to link to. Under Settings > Website the Request form card has a link you can put on your Nextdoor page, your Facebook Page and in your replies. It asks for name, phone or email, what they need done, the address and photos of the work, and each one lands on your Funnel as a new lead with an alert. See Set up online booking and a request form.
- A source on every lead. Add "Nextdoor" and "Facebook group" to your lead sources under Settings > Lists in Lead funnel. When you add a lead by hand with New lead, pick one under How did they find us?. Reports > Marketing then shows leads and won value by source.
- Facebook lead ads. If you run them, Chalk does not pull the leads by itself. They come in through Zapier or Make, and then Chalk can tell Meta which leads booked and paid. See Connect Facebook lead ads to Chalk. Nextdoor ads do not connect to Chalk.
- Chalk does not post or reply for you on Nextdoor or Facebook.
Sources
- Nextdoor, Create a free Business Page and Small business guide to getting Nextdoor Faves and recommendations
- Nextdoor, Changes to self-promotion policy (August 19, 2026)
- Meta, Spam, Community Standards
- Google, Prohibited and restricted content (review incentives)
- FTC, Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: questions and answers and the Endorsement Guides, 16 CFR Part 255
- Scripts and the testing rule are the author's working method, not a study.