Getting a lead is not the hard part for many contractors. The hard part is the gap between "someone asked for a price" and "I am standing in their yard with a tape measure." Leads drop out in that gap: they never answer, they pick someone else, they say "sometime next week" and vanish, or they book a time and are not home.
This guide shows where leads leak, what to ask before you drive out, how to offer times so people say yes, when online booking helps, when a photo replaces the visit, and how to handle no-shows. It assumes the leads are already coming in. If the problem is too few of them, start with how to get more customers. For the first reply, see Speed to lead. For what happens after the visit, see How to follow up on estimates.
Where leads leak
Think of it as a short chain. Each link loses some people. Fix the weakest first.
| Step | Where people leave | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| 1. The lead arrives | Spam, wrong area, wrong service | A form that asks for the address and the job. Skip the obvious misfits fast. |
| 2. You reply | You answer hours later. Someone else got there first. | A reply in minutes. See Speed to lead. |
| 3. A real conversation starts | They don't answer your text. | A reply with a question they can answer in one word, and two times. |
| 4. A time is offered | "Let me check and get back to you." | Offer two specific times and say you will hold one. |
| 5. A time is booked | They book, then forget. | A confirmation now and a reminder the day before. |
| 6. The visit happens | They are not home, or they changed their mind. | Reminders, an "on my way" text, and a rule for no-shows. |
| 7. The quote goes out | You visit, then take five days to send it. | Send it the same day. See How to present an estimate. |
A worked example shows why this matters. Suppose you get 40 leads a month and your chain looks like this:
- You reach 32 of them by phone or text (80%).
- 22 of those agree to a visit (22 of 32, or about 69%).
- 19 of those 22 are home when you arrive (about 86%).
- So you do 19 estimates.
Now you get faster at replying and reach 36 of the 40 (90%), with everything else the same:
36 reached x 0.6875 agree = 24.75 visits booked
24.75 x 0.8636 home = 21.4 estimates
That is about 2.4 more estimates a month from the same marketing. The numbers are made up, but the shape is real: a small gain at the front multiplies through the chain. Count your own steps for a month and you will see where yours leak.
The four questions before you drive out
A drive to a bad lead costs you time and fuel. Ask four short questions before you commit to a visit. You can ask them by text, in a reply to the request form, or on the phone. Want the questions as a form you can print or keep on the phone? Use the customer intake form.
- What is the job, and how big is it? "Is it the whole deck or just the stairs? About how big?" A photo answers this faster than words.
- When do you want it done? "Are you hoping to get it done in the next month, or just getting prices?" This separates ready buyers from people exploring.
- Who decides? "Is it your house? Will anyone else need to see the quote?" You want the owner at the visit. A tenant may not be able to say yes. A couple needs both of them to see it.
- Is there a budget in mind? "Decks like that usually run $X to $Y. Does that sound in the right range?" Say it kindly. It is not rude to talk about money before you drive out. It saves both of you an afternoon.
A script that asks all four without sounding like a form:
Hi Dana, thanks for reaching out. A few quick questions so I can bring the right info: roughly how big is the deck, and are you hoping to get it done this month or just collecting prices? I'd also love a photo if you have one. Decks like that usually run $X to $Y depending on prep. Does that sound like the right range? I can come out Tuesday at 4 or Wednesday at 10.
If they will not answer any of the four, they are probably not ready to buy. Reply politely, keep the door open, and move on to the next lead.
Offer two times, not "when works?"
"When works for you?" makes the customer do the work. Most won't. "Tuesday at 4 or Wednesday at 10?" takes one word to answer.
- Offer two times, on two different days. One is a gamble. Three feels like a menu.
- Include at least one that is outside work hours (early evening or Saturday morning) if your customers work days.
- Say how long you will take. "About 30 minutes."
- Hold the time. "I'll pencil you in for Tuesday at 4."
- If neither works, ask what does: "What day is better? I can do early morning or after 5."
Group your visits by area. If you are already in their part of town on Wednesday, say so: "I'm in Maplewood on Wednesday morning, would 10 work?" A route-friendly time is easier for you, and it is a real reason for them to say yes.
Let them book online
An online booking page lets a customer pick an open time themselves, any hour. It helps when:
- Many leads arrive when you are working or asleep.
- Your customers are used to booking things online.
- You have steady open hours for estimates.
It hurts when:
- Your schedule changes constantly with weather and job overruns.
- You need to qualify the lead first (size, location) because a booking commits you to drive there.
- You are the only person who does estimates, and the page fills your calendar with poor-fit leads.
If you use one, limit it. Set a minimum lead time so nobody books you for an hour from now, a cap on how many visits a day, and only the job types you really want to look at. Read each booking and use the four questions anyway: a text that says "Great, I'll see you Tuesday. Any photos you can send ahead?" costs nothing.
Photo and video estimates
For some jobs you do not need to drive out. Ask for photos and a short walk-around video first. This is how you cut the cost of the visit without losing the customer. The full method, with scripts and what a photo can and cannot tell you, is in Should contractors charge for estimates?.
A request that gets good photos:
To give you an accurate price, could you send: 1) a photo of each side of the fence from the street, 2) a close-up of the worst section, and 3) a 30-second video walking along it? Also tell me the approximate length if you know it.
Then reply with a range right away, and say what the visit would confirm:
Based on the photos I'd estimate $X to $Y. Rot, height and slope can change it, so I'd like to confirm at a short visit. Would Tuesday at 4 or Wednesday at 10 work?
A photo price is a range. A visit gives you a firm number. Use photos to decide who is worth a visit, not to replace every visit.
Confirm, remind, and what to do when they're not home
Most no-shows are not malice. They are forgetfulness. Three small messages fix most of them.
- A confirmation right after booking.
Hi Dana, you're booked with Sam at Hill Country Staining on Tuesday at 4 PM at 123 Elm St. I'll text you before I leave. Reply here if anything changes.
- A reminder the day before, or the morning of the visit.
Hi Dana, a reminder that I'm coming Tuesday at 4 PM to look at the deck. If you need to move it, just reply.
- An "on my way" text when you leave.
Hi Dana, I'm leaving now and will be there in about 15 minutes.
If they are not home:
- Wait 10 to 15 minutes. Call, then text: "Hi Dana, I'm at your house for our 4 o'clock. Are you on your way?"
- Take a photo of the property if you can see it from the street, which helps you price.
- Leave a polite note or door hanger: "Sorry I missed you. Text me to rebook."
- Send a text in the evening, not an angry one: "Hi Dana, sorry we missed each other today. Want to try Thursday at 4 or Friday at 10?"
- Rebook once. A second no-show is a sign. Offer a photo estimate and decline further visits, or charge a trip fee for the next one. See Should contractors charge for estimates?.
Who not to book
Your time is the product. Some leads cost more time than they could ever pay. Decline politely, or send a price range and let them decide.
- Outside your service area, or far enough that the drive eats the margin.
- Under your minimum. Say what your minimum is up front.
- No decision-maker. A tenant who must ask the landlord, a spouse who has not been told.
- Shoppers who refuse to share anything about the job and want a number "over the phone, right now."
- Work you do not do. Send them to someone who does, and you earn a friend.
- Rush jobs that would break your schedule and are not paying rush rates.
A polite decline:
Thanks for thinking of us, Dana. This one is a bit outside what we do, so I don't want to waste your time. [Name] at [business] handles that, and I'd be glad to pass your number along.
How Chalk helps
This part is about our software. Skip it if you only want the advice.
- Request form with photos. The request form asks for name, phone or email, what they need done, the address and optional photos of the work. See Set up online booking and a request form. You cannot add questions to the form, so ask your four questions in your first reply.
- A booking page with real open times. Customers pick a day and an open time and give a street address. You set Soonest they can book (2, 4, 8, 24 or 48 hours), How far ahead, which job types and which people can be booked. Open days and hours, travel time between visits and the cap on visits a day come from Settings > Hours and calendar. It is off until you turn on Let customers pick a time. A booking sends a confirmation and moves the lead to Estimate scheduled.
- Book the estimate from the lead. Open the lead, press Book the estimate, pick the time and who is going. On the Funnel, the panel shows Open times to tap. Booking does not message the customer, so press Confirm with them to send the date and time by text, or email if texting is not set up. See How to book an estimate visit.
- A reminder, on by default. The day-before visit reminder is on for a new shop and covers estimate visits. Chalk skips it on a day the customer already got a confirmation and sends it the morning of the visit instead.
- A checklist for the visit. Under Settings > Lists, a checklist set as Default for quote appointments is added to every new estimate visit, and Convert to quote turns the visit into a draft quote.
- A nudge when you forget. Once the visit time has passed with no quote sent, the lead says "Estimate happened, send the quote". See Work your leads on the Funnel.
- A limit. Chalk has no no-show or cancellation fee. If you want one, say it in your confirmation text and collect it yourself.
Sources
- The leak table, the four questions, the scripts and the sample numbers are the author's working method, not a study. Count your own steps and replace the example numbers with yours.