When a customer gets one price, the only question is "yes or no?" When they get three, the question becomes "which one?" That shift is why good, better, best works. It also fails often, because most tiers are just labels with made-up prices.
This guide builds tiers from your real costs, shows four worked examples with the margin checked on every tier, and covers when options help and when they backfire.
Why options work, and when they backfire
Why they help.
- A "which one" question beats a "yes or no" question. A customer comparing three options is choosing, not deciding whether to hire you.
- The middle tier gets a fair look. A top option makes the middle look reasonable, and a bottom option shows the real price of getting by.
- Customers get a say. They can tie the choice to their budget without asking you to cut your price.
- You stop negotiating the same job. The conversation moves from "can you do it for less?" to "which of these fits?"
When they backfire.
- Too many choices. Three is enough. Five tiers or a long menu of extras makes people put off deciding.
- Tiers that differ only in name. If "best" is the same work as "better" with a nicer label, customers will notice.
- A "good" tier you lose money on. Every tier has to clear your margin. Do not offer a price you hope nobody picks.
- A "good" tier that fails. If the cheap version peels in a year, you own the callback. Make the lowest tier a sound job, not a trap.
- Options on small jobs. A $250 job does not need three versions. Offer one price and optional extras.
We cannot point to a study that says which tier customers pick, and it differs by trade and price range. Track yours. See "Track which tier sells" below.
What changes between tiers
Do not change the price and hope nobody notices. Change something the customer can understand. The usual levers:
| Lever | Good | Better | Best |
|---|---|---|---|
| Prep | Basic | Thorough | Complete |
| Product | Solid mid-grade | Better grade | Top grade |
| Coats or passes | The minimum that works | The recommended number | Extra protection |
| Detail work | Standard | Extra attention | Everything touched |
| Follow-up | None | A check visit | A check visit and a warranty |
| Speed or scheduling | Your next opening | A set week | Priority |
Pick two or three levers per job and keep the language plain. "One coat of penetrating stain" and "two coats, with strip and brighten first" mean something. "Silver" and "Gold" do not.
Price each tier from cost
For each tier, work out your direct cost (materials plus loaded labor), then price to your margin. In these examples:
- Labor is loaded: pay plus payroll costs, as in our hourly rate guide.
- Overhead is 12% of the price.
- Target profit is 20% of the price.
The price comes from dividing cost by what is left after overhead and profit, the same idea as in our markup and margin guide:
Price = Direct cost / (1 - 0.12 - 0.20)
= Direct cost / 0.68
Then round to a clean number and check what profit you really get. These examples are about the method. The hours, materials and rates are made up for illustration, so put your own in.
Four worked examples
Deck and railing staining
A 400 sq ft deck with railing. Labor at $31 an hour.
| Good | Better | Best | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What they get | Clean and brighten, one coat penetrating stain | Strip, brighten, two coats semi-transparent | Full sand, brighten, two coats premium, sealer on end grain |
| Materials | $140 | $310 | $520 |
| Labor hours | 8 | 14 | 22 |
| Labor cost | $248 | $434 | $682 |
| Direct cost | $388 | $744 | $1,202 |
| Price | $570 | $1,095 | $1,770 |
| Overhead (12%) | $68.40 | $131.40 | $212.40 |
| Profit | $113.60 | $219.60 | $355.60 |
| Profit as a share of price | 19.9% | 20.1% | 20.1% |
The jump from good to better is $525 for 6 more hours and $170 more product. The customer is buying a stripped, longer-lasting finish. Our deck stain price calculator gives all three levels from your own measurements.
Exterior painting, small single-story home
Labor at $31 an hour.
| Good | Better | Best | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What they get | Wash, scrape and spot prime, one finish coat on siding, trim touch-up | Full prep, prime bare areas, two coats on siding and trim | Full prep, caulk all seams, two coats premium, doors and shutters color-matched |
| Materials | $520 | $860 | $1,240 |
| Labor hours | 40 | 64 | 92 |
| Labor cost | $1,240 | $1,984 | $2,852 |
| Direct cost | $1,760 | $2,844 | $4,092 |
| Price | $2,590 | $4,180 | $6,020 |
| Overhead (12%) | $310.80 | $501.60 | $722.40 |
| Profit | $519.20 | $834.40 | $1,205.60 |
| Profit as a share of price | 20.0% | 20.0% | 20.0% |
Pressure washing a home
Labor at $31 an hour, counted in person-hours.
| Good | Better | Best | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What they get | Soft wash the house | House plus driveway and walkways | House, driveway, walkways, deck or patio and fence |
| Materials (chemical, fuel) | $60 | $95 | $150 |
| Person-hours | 5 | 11 | 17 |
| Labor cost | $155 | $341 | $527 |
| Direct cost | $215 | $436 | $677 |
| Price | $315 | $640 | $995 |
| Overhead (12%) | $37.80 | $76.80 | $119.40 |
| Profit | $62.20 | $127.20 | $198.60 |
| Profit as a share of price | 19.7% | 19.9% | 20.0% |
On small jobs the good tier barely pays for the trip. Add a minimum charge before the good tier goes below your floor.
House cleaning, 3 bedrooms
Cleaner labor at $24 an hour loaded.
| Good | Better | Best | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What they get | Standard clean | Deep clean: baseboards, doors, inside windows | Deep clean plus oven, fridge, cabinet fronts and walls spot-cleaned |
| Supplies | $12 | $25 | $40 |
| Person-hours | 5 | 9 | 13.5 |
| Labor cost | $120 | $216 | $324 |
| Direct cost | $132 | $241 | $364 |
| Price | $195 | $355 | $535 |
| Overhead (12%) | $23.40 | $42.60 | $64.20 |
| Profit | $39.60 | $71.40 | $106.80 |
| Profit as a share of price | 20.3% | 20.1% | 20.0% |
Notice the pattern in all four: the price steps are driven by hours and materials, so each step has a reason you can say out loud.
Optional extras versus packages
Two different tools do two different jobs.
Packages (good, better, best) replace each other. The customer picks one. Use them when the options change how the whole job is done.
Optional extras stack on top of the chosen job. The customer ticks the ones they want. Use them for add-ons that do not change the core work:
- Staining: railing balusters, stairs, a gate, a second coat on end grain
- Painting: ceilings, garage door, interior doors
- Washing: gutter face, windows, a patio
- Cleaning: oven, fridge, inside windows, laundry
A good pattern is a package for the main decision and a short list of extras for everything else. Mark one or two extras as the ones you recommend, and only the ones you would do yourself. Add-ons by trade, how to offer them and how to price small ones are in add-ons and upsells for service contractors.
How to present it
For the whole conversation, from walking the scope to asking for the deposit, see How to present an estimate so it gets approved. The points below are specific to options.
- Use the same layout for all three. Same fields, same order, so a customer can compare line by line.
- Show what each includes in plain words, not just the name.
- Lead with the one you would pick, and say why: "This is the one I would do on my own deck, because it lasts longer for not much more." Say it only if it is true.
- Do not hide the lowest option. Showing it builds trust, and it shows you are not pushing the top.
- Put the choice in writing. The signed estimate names the tier chosen so there is no argument later about what was included.
- Do not discount the top tier to make the middle look good. If "best" is a poor value, customers will see it. Price all three the same way.
- Offer a way to upgrade. "If you pick good and later want the second coat, we can add it for $[amount]." Keep it simple.
A sample script:
I have priced it three ways so you can pick what fits. The first is a basic refresh and costs $570. The second strips the old finish and adds a second coat, so it lasts longer: $1,095. The third is a full sand and premium stain, $1,770. Which sounds right to you?
If the middle option really is what most of your customers choose, you can say so. Only say it if it is true.
Track which tier sells
After 20 or more quotes, count how many customers picked each tier. If almost everyone takes the bottom, your middle is too expensive or does not look different enough. If almost everyone takes the top, you may be underpricing it, or your top tier is a bargain. If nobody takes the middle, the gap is wrong.
Also track the average job size before and after you start offering options. That is the number that tells you whether it is working.
A small test: for the next ten quotes, send two options (the old single price and one upgrade). If most take the upgrade, you have found money in how you present, not in your price.
How Chalk helps
This part is about our software. Skip it if you only want the pricing advice.
- Optional extras on the quote. Add a line and tick Optional, customer decides, or press + Optional extra. The customer ticks the ones they want on their phone, and the total updates as they do. Tick We recommend it to show a We recommend this badge. See optional extras, timed offers and quote expiry.
- Deposits and timed offers. A quote can carry a deposit, and a timed offer takes money off if the customer approves before a clock runs out. Both are on the same help page.
- A second version of the same quote. Chalk does not put three complete versions of a job side by side on one quote. To offer true good, better and best packages, use the quote's More menu, press Duplicate, and send a second quote for the other version. The extras and the duplicate route cover most of what contractors want from tiers.
- Price from your numbers. The deck stain price calculator is free, works on its own, and gives good, better and best prices at the margin you set.
Sources
- The tier prices in this guide come from the formula Price = Direct cost / (1 - overhead share - profit share). The hours, materials and rates are examples, not market prices. Use the markup and margin calculator to check your own.
- See markup vs margin for why the 0.68 divisor is not the same as adding 32%.
- The deck example follows the packages section of how to price a deck stain job.