Pricing

Markup vs margin for contractors

The difference between markup and margin, the formulas, a conversion chart, and worked contractor examples that show why mixing them up costs you money.

Adrian GluchowskiOwner of Superior Stain Solutions, builder of ChalkLast reviewed 8 min read

On this page

Markup and margin both describe the gap between what a job costs you and what you charge. They use the same dollars but divide by different numbers, so the same percent means two different prices. Mix them up and you can price every job for 40% and end up with 28%.

This guide is the explanation: the two formulas, a chart to convert between them, and examples from real kinds of jobs, labelled as examples. To run your own numbers, use the free markup and margin calculator, which turns a cost into a price and checks what a finished job made.

The two formulas

Markup is profit as a percent of your cost.

Markup = (Price - Cost) / Cost

Margin is profit as a percent of the price.

Margin = (Price - Cost) / Price

A job that costs $1,000 and sells for $1,500 has $500 of profit:

  • Markup: $500 / $1,000 = 50%
  • Margin: $500 / $1,500 = 33.3%

Same job, same $500. Markup always looks bigger than margin, because cost is always smaller than price.

Why margin is the one to steer by

Your books, your accountant and your bank talk in margin. "We kept 20 cents of every dollar we billed" is a margin. Overhead is usually measured as a percent of revenue too, so if you know overhead runs 12% of sales, you need a margin of more than 12% just to break even.

Markup is handy at the counter: "add 25% to the material cost." Just know what margin that gives you.

Getting the price you want

To hit a target margin, divide your cost by one minus the margin:

Price = Cost / (1 - Margin)

For a 40% margin on a $2,000 cost: $2,000 / 0.60 = $3,333.33. The markup and margin calculator does this for you. The calculator rounds up to the cent, so it may show a cent more.

The tempting shortcut, cost times 1.40, is a 40% markup. It gives $2,800, which is only a 28.6% margin.

Step by step: pricing a job to a margin

  1. Add up the job's own costs: materials, labor with payroll taxes, rentals, dump fees and subs. The hourly rate guide shows how to load labor.
  2. Add the job's share of overhead if you are pricing for a net margin. A simple way is overhead as a percent of sales from last year's books.
  3. Pick the margin you want, and write it as a decimal: 40% is 0.40.
  4. Divide the cost by one minus the margin. $2,000 / 0.60 = $3,333.33.
  5. Check it the other way: profit divided by price should give back your margin. $1,333.33 / $3,333.33 = 40%.

If you only remember one line, make it step 4. Multiplying by one plus the margin is the mistake.

Conversion chart

Margin you wantMarkup to useMultiply cost by
10%11.1%1.111
15%17.6%1.176
20%25.0%1.250
25%33.3%1.333
30%42.9%1.429
35%53.8%1.538
40%66.7%1.667
50%100.0%2.000
60%150.0%2.500

To convert yourself:

Margin = Markup / (1 + Markup)
Markup = Margin / (1 - Margin)

Example: the 40% mix-up

A painter prices an exterior job. The costs:

Paint and supplies$500
Labor, with payroll costs$1,100
Overhead share for this job$400
Total cost$2,000

The goal is a 40% margin.

Priced at 40% markupPriced at 40% margin
Price$2,800.00$3,333.33
Profit$800.00$1,333.33
Real margin28.6%40.0%

The mix-up leaves $533.33 on the table on one job. Across 60 jobs that size in a season, that's about $32,000.

Example: what a discount really costs

Same job, priced right at $3,333.33. The customer asks for 10% off, and you agree.

Full priceWith 10% off
Price$3,333.33$3,000.00
Cost$2,000.00$2,000.00
Profit$1,333.33$1,000.00
Margin40.0%33.3%

A 10% discount on the price cut profit by 25%. Every discount dollar comes straight out of profit, because the cost didn't change. Before you offer one, ask what it costs in profit, not in price. If a customer is stuck on price, a smaller option usually beats a discount: see what to say when the price is too high.

Example: gross margin vs net margin

People often say "margin" for two different things.

  • Gross margin counts only the direct costs of the job: materials and labor.
  • Net margin also takes out overhead, the cost of running the business.

On the job above at $3,333.33:

Materials and labor$1,600.00
Gross profit$1,733.33
Gross margin52.0%
Overhead$400.00
Net profit$1,333.33
Net margin40.0%

When someone tells you their margin, ask which one. A 52% gross margin can be a thin business if overhead is high.

Example: marking up materials and subs

Materials. You buy stain at $45 a gallon and mark it up 25%. You charge $56.25. Your margin on the stain is $11.25 / $56.25 = 20%.

A subcontractor. A sub quotes you $1,500 for repair work, and you want a 20% margin on it for managing and guaranteeing it. $1,500 / 0.80 = $1,875. That's a 25% markup.

If you also take card payments, remember the processor takes its cut of the marked-up price too. A 2.9% card fee on the $1,875 is about $54. See can contractors charge a credit card fee for your options.

Example: different targets, one blended margin

Many contractors take a lower margin on materials (the customer can price them at the store) and a higher one on labor (that's your skill and your risk). Check what the whole job comes to.

PartCostTarget marginPrice
Materials$600.0020%$750.00
Labor and overhead$1,400.0045%$2,545.45
Whole job$2,000.00$3,295.45

Profit is $1,295.45, so the blended margin is $1,295.45 / $3,295.45 = 39.3%. If your goal for the business is 40%, this job is close. If the job were mostly materials, the blend would fall toward 20%, so material-heavy jobs need a closer look.

Common mistakes

  • Using markup when you meant margin. The big one. Write the formula on your estimating sheet.
  • Leaving overhead out of cost. Then a "40% margin" is really gross margin, and your net could be half that. The job costing guide shows how to give each job its share.
  • Forgetting labor burden. Payroll taxes and workers' comp are part of labor cost. The hourly rate guide shows how to work them out.
  • One markup for everything. Materials, labor and subs carry different risks. Many contractors use different targets for each and check the blended margin at the end.
  • Marking up materials only. If the markup only goes on materials, labor-heavy jobs earn almost nothing. Price the whole job, labor included.
  • Measuring against the wrong number. A supplier's discount, a sub's price and your crew's cost are all costs. Margin is always measured against what the customer pays.
  • Not checking the result. After the job, compare the real margin to the target. That's how you learn which jobs actually pay. The Profit on one job part of the calculator does it in a minute.

Margins by trade

People ask what margin a painter, a pressure washer or a lawn crew should aim for. The honest answer is that we could not find reliable, public margin data for those trades. Most "average margin" numbers online are copied from each other with no survey behind them, so we are not going to repeat them.

One source we can point to is the National Association of Home Builders' Remodelers' Cost of Doing Business Study. For fiscal year 2024 it reports remodelers with a 29.9% gross profit margin and a 6.3% net profit margin on average revenue of $2.7 million. That is residential remodeling firms, which are larger and do different work from most one-crew painting, washing, cleaning or lawn businesses, so treat it as a reference point and not a target. See NAHB Eye on Housing.

What to do instead of chasing an average:

  1. Work out your own. Take last year's sales, your direct costs (materials and labor), and your overhead. Gross margin is (sales minus direct costs) / sales. Net margin takes overhead out as well.
  2. Compare job types. Your own books will show that some work pays far better than other work.
  3. Set a target from your costs, using the hourly rate guide, and then check each finished job against it.

Quick mental math

  • A 50% margin is cost times 2.
  • A 33% margin is cost times 1.5.
  • A 25% margin is cost times 1.33.
  • A 20% margin is cost times 1.25.

How Chalk helps

  • Your price book shows each item's price, cost and margin, with margins under 40% in red, so you can see which lines earn their keep. See Price book and measurements.

  • Each job has a profit card that takes materials, labor, card fees and overhead off what the job sold for.

  • Reports has a job profitability list for completed jobs, with cost, profit and margin side by side.

FAQ

What is the difference between markup and margin?

Markup is profit as a percent of your cost. Margin is profit as a percent of the price. A job that costs $1,000 and sells for $1,500 has a 50% markup and a 33.3% margin.

Is a 50% markup the same as a 50% margin?

No. A 50% markup on $1,000 is $1,500, a 33.3% margin. A 50% margin needs a price of $2,000, which is a 100% markup.

What markup gives a 40% margin?

66.7%. Divide the margin by one minus the margin, 0.40 / 0.60. In practice, divide your cost by 0.60 to get the price.

What profit margin should a contractor aim for?

We found no reliable public margin data for small painting, washing, cleaning or lawn businesses. NAHB reports remodelers averaged a 29.9% gross and 6.3% net margin in fiscal 2024. Work out your own from last year's books, then set a target from your costs.

Should I use one markup for materials and labor?

Many contractors use a lower target on materials and a higher one on labor, then check the blended margin of the whole job. A job that is mostly materials needs a closer look, because its blend falls toward the lower target.

Sources