Closing the sale

What to say when a customer says your price is too high

Word-for-word answers for "your price is too high", "I'm getting other bids" and "can you do it cheaper", plus when to cut scope instead of price.

Adrian GluchowskiOwner of Superior Stain Solutions, builder of ChalkLast reviewed 11 min read

On this page

"That's more than I expected." Every contractor hears it. How you answer in the next ten seconds decides whether you lose the job, win it at a price that hurts, or win it at a price that works.

This guide covers what "too high" usually means, the one thing to do before you answer, word-for-word replies to six common objections, the math that shows why cutting scope beats cutting price, how to give a discount without teaching customers to haggle, and a one-page sheet to keep in your truck.

What "too high" usually means

The words are the same. The meaning is not.

What they sayWhat it might meanWhat helps
"That's more than I expected."They had no number in mind. You are the first price they have seen.Show what the price includes. They need a reference.
"Another company is cheaper."They are comparing, and may not be comparing the same job.Compare line by line.
"Can you do better?"A habit. Some people always ask.A calm "no" with a friendly alternative.
"I don't have that in the budget."A real limit.Cut scope, stage the work or wait.
"I'll think about it."Doubt about the price, you, or the whole project.Ask what is behind it.
SilenceMany things.Follow up with a question, not a discount.

Treat "too high" as information. It rarely means "I will never pay that." More often it means "I don't yet see why this costs that."

Ask before you answer

The biggest mistake is to answer the price instead of the person. If you drop your number the moment someone frowns, you teach them (and yourself) that the first number was padded.

Ask one question first. Stay calm and curious:

Thanks for telling me. Which part feels high to you: the total, or something specific in the scope?

or

Help me understand. Was there a number you had in mind?

or

Is it a budget thing, or are you comparing it to another quote?

Then listen, and don't fill the silence. The answer tells you which reply below to use. People often say something like "my neighbor paid $1,800 for his fence" or "I only wanted to spend about $2,000." That is the real conversation.

If the answer is "I just want to get the best price," skip ahead to the section on other bids.

Answers to copy (six objections)

Use your own words. These are starting points. Fill in brackets.

1. "That's more than I expected."

I hear you. Here's what the price covers: [prep, product, coats, cleanup, warranty]. Prep is most of the cost, and it's what makes it last [X] years instead of two. If the total is higher than you planned, I can show you a couple of ways to bring it down. Want to see them?

Why it works: it names value, then offers a change, and leaves the price alone.

2. "I'm getting other bids."

That's smart, you should. When you have them, compare what each one covers: how they prep, what product and how many coats, whether they carry insurance, and what the warranty is. Two quotes with the same total can be very different jobs. Would you like me to look at what the others include and tell you honestly whether they match?

Why it works: you welcome the comparison, and you stay on scope, not price. Don't badmouth the other company. If their bid is lower for the same scope, they may be the better fit for this customer, and that is fine.

3. "Can you do it cheaper?" (the discount ask)

I don't want to just cut the number, because then I'd have to cut something real, and I don't want to do that to your job. What I can do is change the scope. For example, [skip the trim / do the front and sides now and the back next spring / use a single coat on the shed]. Want me to price that?

If you do have room and want the job, see "When a discount is fine" below.

4. "Someone else quoted [lower number]."

Thanks for sharing that. It could well be a fair price for what they're doing. Mine includes [list]. Can you tell me what theirs covers, so I can see if we're comparing the same thing?

Then listen. If it is the same scope and the same quality, and the gap is large, you may not be the right fit, and you may be better off losing this one. If it is not the same scope, point out the differences gently and let them decide.

5. "It's just not in the budget right now."

I understand. Let me think about a plan that fits. We could do the most urgent part now, [the deck floor], and add the rest in the spring, at today's price if you book by [date]. Or if you want to wait, I can hold the quote through [date] and call you then. Which is better?

Why it works: it respects the limit and gives two paths, both of which keep the relationship.

6. "We'll just do part of it ourselves," or "I can get a cheaper product."

That's your call, and I'm happy to price the part you want me to do. I'd just tell you which parts are worth doing right and which you can handle: prep on the lower boards is easy to DIY, but the sprayed coat is where the cost and skill are. If you do the prep, I can take [X] off. Want me to write it up that way?

Be clear on who owns the result. If they do the prep and it fails, the warranty may change. Say so in writing.

Cut scope, not price

When a customer needs a lower number, you can lower the price by doing less work or by doing the same work for less money. They are not equal. The math shows why.

Say a job is priced at $3,000. It costs you $1,800 (materials, labor and your share of overhead). That is $1,200 profit, a 40% margin.

Option A: a 20% discount, same work.

New price  = 3,000 x 0.80 = 2,400
Cost       = 1,800 (the work is the same)
Profit     = 2,400 - 1,800 = 600
Margin     = 600 / 2,400 = 25%

You gave up half your profit ($1,200 to $600) to give the customer 20% off.

Option B: remove $600 of work that costs you $360 to do.

New price  = 3,000 - 600 = 2,400
Cost       = 1,800 - 360 = 1,440
Profit     = 2,400 - 1,440 = 960
Margin     = 960 / 2,400 = 40%

The customer still pays $2,400, the same as in option A. But you make $960, not $600, and your margin is untouched, because you're doing less work for less money.

Both options bring the price down to $2,400. Only one of them also keeps your margin. Look for scope that you can remove cleanly: a second coat on a low-visibility area, a service the customer can do themselves, work that can be a second phase, or a lower-grade material they choose knowing the tradeoff.

You can check numbers like these with the markup and margin calculator.

What a discount really costs you

A discount comes straight out of profit. How many more jobs do you need to win just to break even?

Extra volume needed = Old profit / New profit - 1

At a 40% margin, on that $3,000 job ($1,200 profit):

DiscountNew priceNew profitExtra jobs needed to earn the same
5%$2,850$1,05014.3% more
10%$2,700$90033.3% more
15%$2,550$75060% more

Few contractors can grow volume by a third because they gave a 10% discount. That is why the discount "to win the job" is more expensive than it feels.

When a discount is fine, and how to give one

You don't have to hold the price in every case. A discount is a business decision. It is fine when:

  • It fills a real gap. An empty week costs you money anyway. A smaller job in that week is better than none.
  • You get something for it. A bigger job, a deposit now, flexible dates, a review, a referral or a recurring contract.
  • It's for a reason you can say out loud. A bundle of services, a neighbor job on the same day (you save a trip), or a customer who has used you three times.
  • It doesn't go below your floor (next section).

How to give one without teaching the habit:

  1. Make it conditional: "If you can approve by Friday and we can be flexible on the day, I can do $X off."
  2. Give a reason and a number, not "I'll see what I can do."
  3. Write it on the quote. An unwritten discount becomes an argument later.
  4. Give it once. Do not come back with another $100 off after they say "hmm."
  5. Let it expire. A deadline is honest when the reason is real.

I can take $150 off if we can do it on Tuesday when I'm already in your neighborhood, and if you approve by Friday. Would that work?

Notice that this discount is paid for by a real saving (a combined trip), not by your margin.

Getting other bids

Don't be afraid of this one. Customers who get other bids are doing what careful buyers do.

  • Ask what they've received, not who. "What did the others include?" is a fair question. Some will share.
  • Don't race to the bottom. If your bid is higher, it should be for a reason you can explain: prep, product, insurance, warranty, speed.
  • Mention insurance and license once, factually: "We carry liability insurance and workers' comp and I can send you the certificate." Customers don't always know to ask. Don't attack others for lacking it.
  • Beware of bids that look far too low. Very low bids sometimes mean skipped prep, thin product or no insurance. Say so only if you can describe it politely.
  • Offer to hold your quote while they decide.

A reply when they say, "The other guy is $800 less":

It's possible he's the right choice for you. If it helps, here's what's in my number that I'd check for in his: [two coats of X product], [we repair soft boards], [cleanup], [one-year warranty]. If his includes the same, go with whoever you feel best about. If not, I'd love to do it for you.

Then stop. You do not need to win every quote. See Why you lose estimates for how to find out which ones you should have won.

Know your walk-away number

Before you ever sit down with a customer, decide the lowest price you'll accept, and write it on the estimate sheet. Without a floor, every conversation is a negotiation with your own fear.

Floor price from your cost and the lowest margin you'll take:

Floor price = Cost / (1 - Lowest margin)

On the $1,800 cost with a floor margin of 30%:

Floor = 1,800 / 0.70 = 2,571.43, so $2,575

Anything below $2,575 on this job is a job you are choosing to do at a lower margin than you decided you need. It's fine to do that on purpose, once, for a reason. It's not fine to find out later.

Your floor margin should cover your overhead and pay you. See How to figure your hourly rate and job costing if you aren't sure what yours is.

A one-page script sheet to print

Print this, fold it, and keep it in the truck.

They sayAsk firstThen say
"More than I expected.""Which part feels high?""Here's what it covers. I can show you ways to bring it down."
"I'm getting other bids.""What do the others include?""Compare prep, product, coats, insurance and warranty. Want me to look?"
"Can you do cheaper?""Is there a number you had in mind?""I'd rather change the scope than cut corners. Want me to price [option]?"
"Someone quoted less.""Does theirs cover [the list]?""They may be the right fit. Here's what mine includes."
"Not in the budget.""What's the budget we're working with?""We can do the most urgent part now and the rest in spring."
"I'll do part myself.""Which part?""Great. Here's what to leave to us and what to do. I'll write it up that way."

Never:

  • Drop the price in the same breath.
  • Say "I can do it for less" without knowing your floor.
  • Trash another contractor.
  • Promise a discount you haven't written down.
  • Apologize for your price.

How Chalk helps

This part is about our software. Skip it if you only want the sales advice.

  • Change the quote and resend it. Press Edit quote on a sent quote, change the lines, and press Send again. The customer opens the same link and sees the new numbers. The expiry moves forward if it passed. See Change a quote after it is sent.
  • Let the customer drop things themselves. Mark lines as Optional, customer decides and they tick what they want. The total updates as they go. See Optional extras, timed offers and quote expiry.
  • A discount with a deadline. A Timed offer takes a dollar or percent amount off if the customer approves before a clock runs out. It stacks with ordinary discounts. It costs real margin, so run the numbers first.
  • A second version of the quote. Chalk does not show two complete versions side by side. Use More > Duplicate and send the copy as the second option.
  • Record why you lost. When you mark a lead lost on the Funnel, one of the reasons is Price. Over time that shows how often price is the issue. See Work your leads on the Funnel and Reports.
  • What Chalk does not do. It does not tell you what to say or set a floor price. The margin math above is yours to run.

Sources