Running the business

How to set up profit share for a painting or staining crew

A plain plan for crew profit share: how to define job profit, pick a pool and a split, when to pay it, the overtime rule, and worked examples.

Adrian GluchowskiOwner of Superior Stain Solutions, builder of ChalkLast reviewed 8 min read

On this page

Hourly pay buys time. It doesn't reward a crew for finishing a deck in one day instead of two, for not wasting stain, or for doing it right so you never get the callback. Profit share does. When the crew gets a piece of what each job makes, they start caring about the same things you do.

If you want a simpler crew bonus or a production bonus instead, or are deciding between hourly, day rate and piece rate pay first, start with day rate, hourly or piece rate: how to pay your crew.

Profit share only works if the rules are clear before the first job, the math is the same every time, and you pay it when you said you would. This guide shows how to set it up. The examples use a painting and staining crew, but the method fits any trade.

Why profit share works

A crew controls a lot of what a job makes:

  • Hours. Good setup, a clear plan and less standing around.
  • Materials. Less waste, fewer extra runs to the store.
  • Rework. Doing it right once instead of coming back.
  • The customer. A happy customer pays on time and refers neighbors.

Profit share ties pay to all four. A bonus based on revenue only rewards selling big jobs. A bonus based on hours rewards speed even when the work is sloppy. A share of job profit rewards a fast job done right, because rework and wasted material come out of the same pot.

It also teaches the crew how the business works. After a few jobs they understand why prep time matters and why a callback hurts.

Define job profit before the first job

Write down exactly what goes in. If the crew can't predict the number, they won't trust it.

Job profit = Revenue
           - Materials
           - Labor
           - Overhead

Revenue. What the customer pays for the work. Leave out sales tax, and leave out card fees the customer paid back to you, since those just cover your cost.

Materials. The real receipts for the job: stain, paint, cleaner, tape, plastic, sandpaper, rentals. Subtract any returns. Use receipts, not the estimate, once they're in.

Labor. Every hour anyone worked on the job, times their pay rate, plus your labor burden: the payroll taxes, workers' comp and other costs that come with each hour. Our hourly rate guide shows how to figure burden. Include drive time to the job if you pay it.

Overhead. Your share of the costs that keep the business running: truck, insurance, phone, software, office, marketing, your accountant. The simple way is a fixed percent of revenue. Take last year's overhead and divide by last year's revenue. If overhead was $54,000 on $450,000 of work, that's 12%.

Two more rules to write down:

  • A job that loses money pays no share. Never take a loss out of someone's regular pay.
  • Warranty work found before the share is paid counts against that job. After that, treat it as overhead, so nobody's pay is clawed back.

Pick the pool and the split

The pool is the percent of job profit that goes to the crew. There is no standard number. Pick one you can afford on your thinner jobs, not just the good ones. The examples below use 15%.

The split decides who gets what from the pool. Three common ways:

SplitHow it worksGood for
By hoursEach person's share of the hours on the jobCrews where everyone does similar work
By role weightA lead counts as 1.5, a helper as 1.0, then by hours times weightCrews with a clear lead
Flat percentThe lead gets a set percent of profit, helpers anotherSmall crews that stay the same

Splitting by hours is the easiest to explain and the hardest to argue with.

Worked example: a good job

A deck and fence stain job sold for $4,800. The customer paid by check. Three people worked it.

PersonHoursRateWages
Lead16$26$416.00
Tech A12$20$240.00
Tech B12$18$216.00
Total40$872.00

Say your labor burden is 12% (use your own number). Labor cost is $872.00 x 1.12 = $976.64.

Revenue$4,800.00
Materials (receipts)-$620.00
Labor with burden-$976.64
Overhead at 12% of revenue-$576.00
Job profit$2,627.36
Crew pool at 15%$394.10

Split by hours (40 total):

PersonShare of hoursProfit shareExtra per hour worked
Lead16 / 40 = 40%$157.64$9.85
Tech A12 / 40 = 30%$118.23$9.85
Tech B12 / 40 = 30%$118.23$9.85

Worked example: the same job gone wrong

Same job, but the crew skipped a proper rinse, the stain blotched on one section, and they had to strip and redo it. That took 14 more hours (Lead 4, Tech A 5, Tech B 5) and $180 more in materials.

Revenue$4,800.00
Materials-$800.00
Labor with burden ($1,166 in wages x 1.12)-$1,305.92
Overhead at 12%-$576.00
Job profit$2,118.08
Crew pool at 15%$317.71

Now the lead gets $117.67 for 20 hours, about $5.88 extra per hour instead of $9.85. Nobody had to give a speech about rinsing. The number did it.

When to pay it

Pay when the job is finished and the costs are in. That means the work is done, the customer has signed off, and every receipt and every hour is entered. Then the profit is a real number, and you pay the share on the next payday.

Paying on unfinished jobs causes trouble:

  • The number moves. Receipts arrive late, a return gets credited, a touch-up visit adds hours. You paid on a profit that later shrank.
  • Clawbacks are a mess. Taking money back from someone's next check feels like a pay cut, and many states limit deductions from wages. Better never to overpay in the first place.
  • It rewards starting, not finishing. A crew paid on jobs in progress has less reason to wrap up the last 10%.
  • Rework hides. If the share is paid before the final walkthrough, the cost of fixing problems lands on you alone.

Some shops wait until the customer has paid in full. That protects you from a customer who never pays, but it makes the crew wait on something they can't control. A middle path: pay on finish, and only hold the share when the customer has a real complaint about the work.

On long jobs, you can pay a share per phase if each phase has its own finished price and costs.

The overtime rule

Under the federal Fair Labor Standards Act, a bonus you promise in advance (like a profit share with a set formula) is "nondiscretionary," and it has to be included in the regular rate used for overtime for hourly, non-exempt employees. So in a week with overtime, the share raises the overtime owed.

Example: Tech A earns $20 an hour, works 46 hours, and earns a $118.23 share that week.

Regular rate
  = (46 x $20 + $118.23) / 46
  = $22.57
Overtime half-time
  = 0.5 x $22.57 x 6 hours
  = $67.71
Week's pay
  = $920 + $118.23 + $67.71
  = $1,105.94

Without the share, the overtime half-time would have been $60.00, so the share added $7.71 in overtime. If a job spans several weeks, the federal rules spread the bonus back over those weeks. Your payroll provider can handle it, but only if you tell them the payment is a profit share and not a gift.

A profit share is wages, so payroll taxes apply to it too. Budget for that.

Pitfalls

  • Changing the formula after the job. If overhead jumps from 12% to 18% because you had a slow month, the crew will notice. Change the plan only for future jobs, in writing.
  • Hiding the numbers. Show each person the job's profit summary. They don't need your whole books, just the lines in the formula.
  • Paying on the estimate. The estimate is a guess. Pay on the real result.
  • Sharing on revenue by mistake. "10% of the job" and "10% of the profit" are very different numbers. On the good job above, 10% of revenue is $480. 10% of profit is $262.74.
  • Letting it replace fair base pay. Keep hourly pay at a fair market rate. The share is on top.
  • Shares on jobs someone didn't work. Only the people with hours on the job share in it.
  • No written plan. One page is enough: the formula, the pool, the split, when it's paid, and what happens with losses and callbacks.

A one-page plan you can copy

  1. Who: everyone who logs hours on a job.
  2. Job profit: revenue (less sales tax and card fees paid back) minus material receipts, minus labor at pay rate plus 12% burden, minus overhead at 12% of revenue.
  3. Pool: 15% of job profit. No share on a job that loses money.
  4. Split: by hours worked on the job.
  5. When: on the next payday after the job is finished and all costs are entered.
  6. Callbacks: charged to the job if found before the share is paid; overhead after.
  7. Changes: only for future jobs, with two weeks' written notice.

Put your own numbers in, and have everyone sign it.

How Chalk helps

Chalk tracks job profit on every job and can pay a profit share from it.

  • A job's profit card shows revenue against materials, labor at each person's rate when they clocked in, card fees, overhead and any pay split out of the job.
  • Under Pay setup, set Overhead as a percent of what the job sold for and a Fixed job cost for each job. Both start at zero. Labor counts at pay rate, so add your burden through overhead or the fixed cost.
  • On a job, Pay someone from this job offers a flat amount, a percent of the job, or a percent of the profit.
  • Profit shares are owed when the job is finished. Until then they show as in progress, whatever your regular pay timing is.

Sources