Running the business

Hiring your first helper: W-2 or 1099?

General info for small contractors hiring a first helper: employee vs subcontractor tests, workers' comp, what an employee really costs, and paperwork.

Adrian GluchowskiOwner of Superior Stain Solutions, builder of ChalkLast reviewed 11 min read

On this page

Sooner or later the work outgrows you. A second set of hands lets you take more jobs, finish faster and stop turning people away. The first hire is also where many small contractors make an expensive mistake: they call a helper a 1099 subcontractor because it seems cheaper, and the labor agency, the IRS or the helper's injury claim says otherwise.

This guide explains how the employee versus subcontractor question is decided, what an employee really costs, what to collect if you do use subs, and what the first two weeks should look like. It is general information, written for small service contractors in the US. Still deciding whether you have the work and the money to hire at all? Start with from solo to a crew, which covers the numbers and the order to add people.

Employee or subcontractor: the tests

The first thing to understand is that you do not get to choose. What decides whether someone is an employee is how the working relationship really works, not the label on a form or what you agree between you.

The IRS test

The IRS looks at the whole relationship, in three groups of evidence:

GroupThe questionPoints to an employeePoints to a contractor
BehaviorDo you control, or have the right to control, what the worker does and how?You set hours, give detailed instructions, train them your wayThey decide how and when to do the work and you only review the result
MoneyDo you control the business side?You pay by the hour, supply tools and truck, reimburse expensesThey bring their own tools and insurance, quote a price, can profit or lose
RelationshipHow is the arrangement set up?Ongoing, indefinite, doing your core work, benefitsOne project at a time, a written contract, also working for other customers

No single factor decides it. See the IRS page Independent contractor (self-employed) or employee?. If you are unsure, either you or the worker can ask the IRS for an official ruling on Form SS-8, though it can take months. IRS Publication 15-A has a section on it.

The Department of Labor test

For wage and overtime law (the Fair Labor Standards Act), the Department of Labor asks a different question: is the worker economically dependent on you, or truly in business for themselves? The factors include how much control you have, whether the worker can make a profit or take a loss through their own initiative or investment, how much they invest, how permanent the relationship is, and whether the work is a regular part of your business.

The federal rule has changed back and forth. As of the sources we checked in October 2026, the Department of Labor was enforcing the older Fact Sheet 13 and had proposed a new rule in early 2026 that had not been finalized. Check dol.gov for the current version. Courts and states can apply their own tests.

State tests

Many states have their own rules for unemployment insurance, workers' comp and wages, and some are stricter than federal law. Some use an "ABC test," which makes it much harder to treat someone as a contractor, for example if the work they do is part of your usual business. California is a well-known example. Your state labor department can tell you which test applies. The DOL lists state labor offices.

Quick gut check

Someone is more likely a true subcontractor if they:

  • Have their own business name, tools, truck and insurance
  • Quote you a price for the job, and can lose money if it runs long
  • Choose their own schedule and methods
  • Work for other contractors or customers
  • Are not trained by you or dependent on you for most of their income

Someone is more likely an employee if they:

  • Work the hours you assign, in your truck, with your equipment
  • Are paid by the hour or day to do what you tell them
  • Work for you only, week after week
  • Do the same core work as your own crew

A helper who shows up at 7 am, uses your ladder and sprayer, is told how to do the job, and has no other customers is an employee, whatever you call them.

What goes wrong

If a worker you treated as a contractor is later found to be an employee, you can owe back payroll taxes, penalties and interest, unpaid overtime, unemployment insurance and workers' comp costs. If they are hurt on your job and you have no workers' comp coverage, you can face a claim and fines on top. The IRS has a Voluntary Classification Settlement Program (Form 8952) for businesses that want to reclassify workers going forward with partial relief. A tax professional can tell you if it applies to you.

What an employee really costs

The wage is the smallest surprise. Our hourly rate guide works out a $22 an hour employee, paid for 1,900 hours a year, with Social Security and Medicare, federal and state unemployment, and workers' comp. The loaded cost is $47,817.70 a year, which is about $30.91 for every hour you can actually bill, 1.4 times the wage, before any overhead or profit. The unemployment and comp rates in that example are made up, so use your own.

A seasonal helper, worked

A helper at $20 an hour for 13 weeks of 40 hours (520 hours):

Wages: 520 x $20$10,400.00
Social Security and Medicare (employer share, 7.65%)$795.60
Federal unemployment (0.6% of the first $7,000, in most states)$42.00
State unemployment (example: 2.7% of a $10,000 wage base)$270.00
Workers' comp (example: $6.00 per $100 of payroll)$624.00
Total$12,131.60

That is about 16.7% on top of the wages (the extras come to $1,731.60), before you count paid time off, equipment, training time or your own paperwork hours. The Social Security and Medicare rates are the 2026 employer rates from the IRS: see Topic 751. Federal unemployment is 0.6% in most states, but employers in a credit reduction state pay more (California for 2025: 1.8%, or $126 on the first $7,000). See the Labor Department's FUTA credit reductions.

If you use subs: what to collect

There are real subcontractors, such as an established painter who takes your overflow, an electrician for a small repair, or a pressure washer with their own rig. If you use them, protect yourself with paperwork.

Before they start:

  1. A written agreement. Scope of work, price, schedule, who supplies materials and equipment, insurance requirements, payment terms, and a statement that they run their own business and control how they do the work. See the sample below.
  2. A completed Form W-9. It gives you their legal name and tax ID. You need it to file their 1099. See About Form W-9.
  3. A certificate of insurance. Ask for general liability, and for workers' comp or proof they are exempt under your state's rules. Ask your own insurer how it treats uninsured subs, because many policies charge extra for them and some states can hold you responsible for an uninsured sub's workers.
  4. Their license, if your state or city requires one for the work they do.

While they work:

  1. Pay against an invoice from their business, for the job, not for hours on your schedule.
  2. Do not tell them how to do the work or when to be on site beyond the job's real requirements.

At year end:

  1. File a Form 1099-NEC for anyone you paid $2,000 or more for services in the year, for payments made after 2025. The threshold is set to be adjusted for inflation from 2027. Read the current IRS Instructions for Forms 1099-MISC and 1099-NEC for the deadline and for backup withholding when a sub does not give you a taxpayer ID.

A sample line for the agreement:

[Sub name] is an independent contractor and not an employee of [your business]. [Sub name] controls the means and methods of the work, supplies their own tools and insurance, and is responsible for their own taxes. [Your business] will pay the agreed price of $[amount] on completion and receipt of an invoice.

A paper alone does not make someone a contractor, but the missing paper can make it look worse.

If you hire an employee: the paperwork

Putting someone on the payroll is more work than just handing over cash. It is worth the work, because it keeps you legal and keeps you insured.

  • An EIN from the IRS, if you do not have one. See Get an EIN.
  • Form W-4 from the employee, so you know how much income tax to withhold. See About Form W-4.
  • Form I-9 to verify the person can work in the US. Employers must complete it for every person they hire. See USCIS I-9.
  • New hire reporting to your state. Federal law requires you to report each new hire to your state's directory within 20 days of hire, and some states require it sooner. See ACF's new hire reporting page.
  • Payroll taxes: withhold and pay income tax, Social Security and Medicare, plus the employer share and unemployment tax. See the IRS employment taxes page.
  • Workers' comp insurance, as your state requires. The employee count that triggers it varies by state, and some states require it from the first hire. The SBA explains the basics on its business insurance page.
  • State rules on pay stubs, pay frequency, minimum wage and overtime. Your state labor office is the source.
  • A payroll service. Most small contractors use one so taxes are filed on time. It costs less than one penalty.

Can you pay an employee in cash?

Paying wages in cash is not illegal by itself. Treating cash as a way to skip the paperwork is. If someone is your employee, you must still withhold and pay payroll taxes, report the wages, keep records and give them a W-2. Pay a cash employee "off the books" and you can end up with the same back taxes and penalties as any misclassification, plus an angry employee who cannot prove income for a loan or an apartment. Run it through payroll, and pay by direct deposit or check so there is a record.

Where to find helpers

  • Your own network: past customers, suppliers and other contractors often know someone. A referral from a person you trust beats an ad.
  • Local job boards and community groups.
  • Trade schools and community college programs, and workforce offices in your county.
  • Your slow-season contacts: a person who worked a competitor's busy season may want steadier hours.
  • Your own signs and trucks: a "now hiring" line on the truck costs nothing.

Hiring for a busy season only? See hiring seasonal crew. Not sure you are ready yet? See from solo to a crew for the numbers.

Pay for any trial day. A person doing real work for you is generally owed wages for it. Call it a paid trial day and put it on the books.

When you interview, ask about reliability before skill. You can teach a ladder technique, but you cannot teach showing up. Ask for two references and call them.

The first two weeks

A good first fortnight sets the tone for everything after. Our 30-day training plan carries on from here. Print the crew onboarding checklist for day one.

Before day one:

  • Paperwork done (W-4, I-9, direct deposit form) and the pay schedule explained.
  • Work clothes, gloves, eye protection and a respirator sized to them.
  • A short written list of what you expect: start time, phone rules, how to talk to customers, what to do when something goes wrong.

Week one:

  • Work beside them. Show the whole job, not only the task: setup, protecting the customer's property, the work, and cleanup.
  • Teach safety first: ladders, chemicals (read the label and safety data sheet together), heat, and lifting.
  • Give small tasks with clear standards, and check them at the end of each day.
  • Introduce them to the customer. A customer who knows the helper's name is a customer who is easier to keep.
  • Track hours from day one.

Week two:

  • Give them a defined part of a job to own, like prep on a deck or masking a room.
  • Check quality and speed against your own, and tell them what you see: one thing done well, one thing to improve.
  • Ask what is confusing or slow. They are seeing your systems with fresh eyes.
  • Decide on a review date for pay and next steps, and put it on the calendar.

Mistakes to avoid:

  • Hiring the first warm body because you are busy
  • Paying nothing for training time
  • Skipping the safety talk
  • Handing over customer keys or door codes in the first week
  • Changing the pay deal after the first paycheck
  • Promising hours you cannot deliver in a slow month

How Chalk helps

This part is about our software. Skip it if you only want the hiring advice.

Chalk records what you owe and what you paid. It does not run payroll, withhold taxes or file anything with the IRS or your state.

Sources