Closing the sale

Should you offer financing to customers?

How customer financing works for contractors, what it costs you, which jobs it helps close, how to bring it up, and the questions to ask a lender first.

Adrian GluchowskiOwner of Superior Stain Solutions, builder of ChalkLast reviewed 8 min read

On this page

A homeowner who loves your $14,000 repaint quote may not have $14,000 sitting around. Some of them will wait. Some will take a cheaper bid. Some will ask whether you "do payments." Financing is how you answer.

It is also not free to you, and the wrong setup can hurt your margin or your reputation. This guide explains how financing works, what it really costs, which jobs it helps close, how to bring it up without sounding salesy, and the questions to ask any lender before you sign. It does not recommend a lender. Lender websites are sales pages, so this page sticks to the math and the questions.

How it works: buy now pay later vs a lender

Customer financing comes in a few forms. They behave very differently.

KindHow it worksTypical useWho pays the fee
Pay over time (buy now pay later)The customer chooses a short plan at checkout, often a few payments or monthly installments. The provider pays you, usually the full amount minus its fee, and collects from the customer.Smaller and mid-size amounts: deposits, repairs, one-time services.You, as a fee per payment.
A lender's home improvement loanThe customer applies through the lender's page. If approved, the lender pays you (often in stages or after the job is done) and the customer repays the lender over months or years.Bigger projects.Usually you, as a "merchant" or "dealer" fee. The customer pays interest.
The customer's own moneyHome equity line, personal loan, credit card, savings.Any job.Nobody to you.
You carry itYou let the customer pay you over months.Rarely a good idea.You carry the risk and the wait.

The last one deserves a sentence. If you spread payments yourself, you are the bank: you do the work now and chase the money later. It is the same risk as an unpaid invoice, made official. If a customer needs a plan, use a provider who takes the risk, or use structured stage payments. See Deposits for contractors and What to do when a customer won't pay.

What it costs you, and why you can't just add it on

With most financing products, you pay a fee on each financed job. The fee comes out of what the lender sends you. The customer sees the price you quoted.

The size of the fee depends on the product and the promotion. A plain-rate loan costs you less. A "0% interest for 12 months" offer costs you more, because the lender is paying the interest the customer is not. Fees reported by lenders and financing platforms range from near zero to the low double digits, and the ones I saw are vendor claims, not audited figures. Ask each lender for its schedule in writing.

Here is the effect on one job. You quote $12,000. The job costs you $7,200, so your profit is $4,800 (a 40% margin).

FeeFee in dollarsYou receiveProfitProfit lost
5%$600$11,400$4,20012.5%
8%$960$11,040$3,84020%
10%$1,200$10,800$3,60025%

An 8% fee takes a fifth of your profit on that job. That is the honest cost.

Can you just raise the price on financed jobs? Usually not, or not without trouble:

  • Some lender agreements forbid charging financed customers more. Read yours.
  • A customer who sees a higher number than a friend got feels tricked.
  • Under federal Truth in Lending rules, a higher price for customers who finance than for those who pay cash can count as a hidden finance charge, which the lender would have to disclose. Ask the lender how it handles this.
  • If you raise every price to cover the fee, you raise it for people who pay cash too.
  • Card surcharging has its own rules. See Can contractors charge a credit card fee?.

The cleaner approach is to set your prices to include the cost of offering financing, as you would include insurance or software, and not to list a separate "financing fee." You still need to be sure the whole price is fair and true.

Which jobs it helps

Financing helps most when the quote is large compared with what a household keeps in cash and the customer wants the job. It helps least on small jobs. A $350 gutter cleaning rarely needs a payment plan. A $14,000 repaint, a full fence or a big deck might.

To decide whether it pays for you, ask: how many extra jobs does it have to bring in to cover the fees?

An example. You offer financing on big jobs that average $12,000 with $4,800 profit, and an 8% fee ($960). Say 8 customers use it in a year.

Profit per job after the fee = 4,800 - 960 = 3,840
If x of the 8 would NOT have bought without financing:
   Gain  = x * 3,840
   Cost  = (8 - x) * 960      (the fee on jobs you'd have won anyway)
Break-even: 3,840x = (8 - x) * 960
            4,800x = 7,680
            x = 1.6

So financing needs to turn about 1.6 of those 8 (one in five) into jobs you would otherwise have lost, just to break even. If three of the eight are real extras:

Gain = 3 * 3,840 = 11,520
Cost = 5 * 960   =  4,800
Net  = +6,720

If only one is an extra:

Gain = 1 * 3,840 = 3,840
Cost = 7 * 960   = 6,720
Net  = -2,880

The numbers are made up. The method is not. Track how many financed customers say they would not have signed otherwise. Ask them. After a season you will know.

How to mention it without sounding salesy

Don't lead with financing. Present the quote first. See How to present an estimate. Bring financing up when it helps the customer, in one calm sentence.

When you sense price hesitation:

If it helps to spread the cost out, there's an option to pay over time. You can look at the terms on the lender's own page, no commitment, and it's totally fine if you'd rather pay another way.

When they ask "do you offer payments?":

We do. It's through [provider], and they handle the application and the terms directly with you. I'll send you the link. Anything you decide, it doesn't change the price of the work.

Rules for staying on the right side of this:

  • Never say what the rate or monthly payment will be. You don't know. The lender shows it.
  • Don't enter their information. The customer applies on their own device.
  • Don't pressure. Offer it once.
  • Keep your price the same whether they finance or not. If the customer asks, say so.
  • Don't promise approval. "Subject to approval" is the honest wording.

Questions to ask any lender

Don't sign until you have answers in writing.

  1. What is my fee, by product and promotion? Get the full schedule.
  2. When do I get paid? At approval, when the work starts, when it is done, after the customer signs off? Are there holdbacks?
  3. What if the customer cancels, disputes the work or doesn't pay? Can the lender take the money back from you?
  4. What does the customer see? APR range, deferred interest or true 0%, fees, and who they deal with if they have a problem.
  5. Can I charge the same price to financed and cash customers? Can I charge different prices?
  6. Who handles complaints and collections? Whose name is on the loan?
  7. What credit check is run, and how often are customers declined?
  8. Does my state or license require anything for me to offer or mention financing? Ask the lender and your licensing board.
  9. Is there a contract term, minimum volume or exclusivity, and how do I leave?
  10. Does your platform let customers apply on their own, without me entering anything for them?

Pitfalls

  • Deferred interest surprises. An offer like "no interest if paid in full in 12 months" can mean interest charged from the first day if any balance remains at the end. The CFPB explains how that works. A customer who gets hit with it will blame you. Tell them to read the terms.
  • Loans the customer never asked for. In 2021 the CFPB took action against a company that ran a financing program used mostly by home improvement providers, finding that it originated loans for thousands of consumers who did not request or authorize them (see CFPB: GreenSky). Never apply for a customer, and never click through on their behalf.
  • Payment timing. If the lender pays after completion and you front the materials, financing hurts your cash flow. See Getting paid faster.
  • Approval doesn't come. You promised a date, the customer was declined, and now the job is off. Keep your schedule flexible until the approval lands.
  • Customer shopping. The FTC's advice to homeowners is to never agree to financing through a contractor without shopping around and comparing loan terms. Welcome that. A customer who compared terms is a customer who will not complain later.
  • Cheap rate, high fee. A 0% promotion can be great for the customer and costly for you. Price your work knowing that.

How Chalk helps

This part is about our software. Skip it if you only want the financing advice.

  • Klarna on deposits and invoices. Under Settings > Connectors > Payments, Offer Klarna lets homeowners pay over time. Stripe reviews it, usually within a day or two. Where customers see it is On invoices or On deposits and invoices. Klarna takes $45 to $10,000, and Show it on balances from can raise the floor. You pay 5.99% + 30¢ per payment and it cannot be passed on to the customer. Company and commercial clients never see it. The quote page mentions that financing is available. See Take card and bank payments and Pass card and bank fees to customers.
  • An outside financing link. In the same place, Outside financing link takes the link to your own lender and the button text. Customers see a button to it on estimates and invoices for jobs too big for Klarna, and whenever Klarna is off or not open to them. Leave it empty to show nothing. The lender's page handles the application and the terms. Chalk does not see the application.
  • What Chalk does not do. It does not pick a lender, quote rates, take loan applications or tell you what a financed job costs. The fee math above is yours to run.

Sources