Crew and hiring

Hiring seasonal crew without the spring scramble

When to start hiring for the busy season, where seasonal workers come from, what to pay, how to test them, and how to get your best people back next year.

Adrian GluchowskiOwner of Superior Stain Solutions, builder of ChalkLast reviewed 9 min read

On this page

It is March. The phone is ringing. You have 40 estimates waiting, a crew of two and a plan to "find some guys." So you post on a job board, take the first four people who answer, throw them on a truck with a ladder, and by June two have quit and one has damaged a window. Sound familiar?

Hiring in the busy season means hiring in a panic. The fix is to start earlier, ask for less, test harder and treat seasonal workers like people you want back. This guide is for exterior and lawn trades with a real peak: staining, washing, gutters, painting, mowing, lighting. It does not repeat the legal basics of the first hire, which are in Hiring your first helper.

Start in January

Allow a few weeks from the first message to the first day. If you start in April, you may still be hiring in May.

A simple calendar:

WhenWhat to do
Last OctoberAsk your best seasonal people if they want to come back. Say it before they leave.
JanuaryDecide how many people you need and for how long. Write the job post. Message last year's crew.
FebruaryPost. Interview. Run working interviews on dry days.
Early MarchMake offers. Do paperwork. Order uniforms, gloves, eye protection and respirators.
Mid MarchA paid training week before the rush hits. See training a new crew member.
AprilA full crew in the field.

The reason to hurry is not just the work. It is the pay. A person who waits until April to apply has already had other offers. The best hires are gone in February.

How many do you need? Work backward from your calendar. If your spring schedule is booked at 40 jobs a week and one two-person crew does 12, you need three crews, or fewer jobs. Compare the cost of a seasonal hire to the work they unlock. The affordability math is in going from solo to a crew.

Where seasonal help comes from

  • Your own past crew. The first call. Ask in January.
  • Their friends and family. Ask your best people to recommend someone. A referral that works out brings both of them a bonus (see below). People rarely refer someone who will embarrass them.
  • Students and teachers. College students home for the summer, high school students, and teachers who want summer income. They come with a fixed end date, so tell them yours. Hiring anyone under 18 has limits on hours and on which tasks they can do. See the federal YouthRules site and your state's child labor rules before you hire a teenager for ladders, roofs or power equipment.
  • Trade and vocational schools, and workforce offices in your county.
  • Workers from slower trades. Snow removal, holiday lights, construction and landscaping people often have a gap in spring or summer.
  • A "now hiring" sign on your trucks, your yard signs and your invoices.
  • Local groups and job boards. They work, but they bring volume more than quality. Screen hard.
  • A staffing agency. It costs more per hour, and it takes some of the hiring and payroll off your plate. Ask who carries the workers' comp.
  • The H-2B visa program. For some employers with a true seasonal need, the federal H-2B program allows hiring foreign workers for temporary non-farm jobs. It has an annual cap that is split between two halves of the year, it requires a labor certification from the Department of Labor, and the paperwork starts months before the job (DOL's filing window is 75 to 90 days before the date of need, and a prevailing wage request comes before that). Most small crews do not use it, and an immigration attorney or a program agent is the right help. See the DOL's H-2B program page and USCIS's H-2B page.

Write a job post people answer

A good post is specific, honest and short. Most posts for seasonal trades say "must be reliable, hard worker, own transportation" and nothing else. People skim past them.

Include:

  • The pay, as a number. "$18 to $22 an hour, based on experience." A post with no pay gets fewer, worse applicants.
  • The dates. "March 15 to October 31, with a chance to stay on."
  • The hours and the days. "Monday to Friday, 7 AM to about 4 PM. Some Saturdays."
  • What the work is. "House washing, deck staining and gutter cleaning. Ladders and heights."
  • What you give. "Paid training. Uniform and safety gear. A bonus for finishing the season."
  • What you need. "A valid ID, a way to get to the shop by 7, ability to lift 50 lbs, and comfort on a ladder."
  • How to apply, in a way that takes under two minutes: a text, a short form, or a phone number.

An example:

Seasonal crew, house washing and deck staining. [Your town] shop, March 15 to October 31. $18 to $22 an hour depending on experience. Paid training the first week. Mon to Fri, 7 to about 4. You'll work on ladders and outdoors in the heat. We provide gear. Finish the season and get a $1.50 an hour bonus. Text Sam at (number) with your name and one line about your last job.

A one-line question in the application ("tell me about your last job") filters well. People who answer in a sentence are usually people who answer a text on the job.

A paid working interview

You cannot learn much from a conversation. Watch someone work.

A working interview is a short, paid shift on a real job where you can watch. For example, a half day on a simple task such as prep work, loading, cleanup or a lawn. Pay for the time. The Fair Labor Standards Act requires for-profit employers to pay employees for their work, and a person doing real work for your business in a trial is generally an employee. See the Department of Labor's Fact Sheet 71. Make the offer for the trial shift first, then put them on the books for it: a W-4, a Form I-9 and the hours worked. For a job that lasts fewer than three business days, the I-9 has to be finished by the end of the first day, so have them bring their ID documents.

What to watch:

  • Did they show up on time, with the right shoes and a water bottle?
  • Do they listen? Do they ask a question, or pretend to understand?
  • Are they careful? Do they check their ladder, move things, wipe their feet?
  • Are they steady? Pace matters more than speed.
  • How do they take correction?
  • How do they speak to the customer?

A simple scorecard (1 to 5 each): on time, listens, careful, pace, attitude, safety. Anything below 3 on safety or attitude is a no, however good the pace.

Always call the references.

What to pay, and the return bonus

Pay competes with every other seasonal shop. Check local job posts for the going rate and set yours so you do not lose a good person for a dollar.

Three ways to make the offer stronger without raising the base:

  1. A completion or return bonus. A bonus paid at the end of the season to people who stay through the last day. Example: $1.50 an hour for every hour worked, paid with the last check. A helper who works 520 hours earns $780 (520 x $1.50).
  2. A referral bonus. A bonus when a referred hire finishes 60 days.
  3. A raise at a milestone. After training sign-offs, such as $1 an hour after 30 days. See training a new crew member.

Is the return bonus worth it? Compare it to the cost of a mid-season quit. A made-up example: you lose a helper in July, and it takes 16 hours of your time at $60 an hour to find and train a replacement ($960), and the new person works at 70% of the old person's pace for 40 hours at $20 an hour ($240 of wasted wages). That is $1,200 for one quit. With three helpers the bonus costs $2,340 if all three stay, so it pays for itself if it prevents about two mid-season quits. Most owners find it does, but count your own quits first.

Overtime and bonuses. If a bonus is promised in advance with a formula, it is generally part of the "regular rate" for overtime, so hours over 40 are paid at a higher rate. Overtime rules apply to day rates too. See day rate vs hourly crew pay for the math. A discretionary surprise bonus is treated differently, so ask your payroll provider which kind you have.

Paperwork for every hire

Seasonal workers are employees like any other, so the same rules apply: a W-4, an I-9, new-hire reporting to your state, payroll taxes, workers' comp and state labor rules. The full list is in Hiring your first helper.

A few seasonal points:

  • Do not call them 1099 to save money. The test is the relationship, not the label.
  • Your workers' comp and unemployment rates may change with the payroll you report. Tell your agent when your payroll will jump.
  • Seasonal workers and unemployment. Rules on who can claim unemployment between seasons differ by state. Your state workforce agency can tell you how it works, and the Department of Labor lists them at dol.gov.
  • Write down end dates and tell people early if the season is ending sooner than expected.
  • Minors. Check federal and state limits before you hire anyone under 18 (see above).

Keep in touch over winter

You do not need to employ someone to stay on good terms with them.

  • Send a note in November. "Thanks for the season. We'll start hiring in January. I'd love to have you back."
  • Ask what they would change. A 10-minute call is enough.
  • Send a text in January with the start date and pay.
  • Offer a first pick. "Returners get first choice of start date and crew."
  • Give a small winter job if you have one (equipment cleaning, shop work, snow). Our guide on off-season work has ideas.
  • Tell them what you are doing. People disappear when they do not know whether there is a next season.

See how to keep good crew members for the longer view.

How Chalk helps

This part is about our software. Skip it if you only want the hiring advice.

  • Seats for each person. Each person after the owner is a seat at $14 a month, or $140 a year on a yearly plan. Invite seasonal crew under Settings > Team with Invite someone, and when they leave, switch off or remove their account. A freed seat stays on your bill until you press Remove a seat under Settings > Billing, so do that when the season ends. See Add your team and Plans and billing.
  • A limited view for field crew. The Field crew role sees only the visits they are on, with no prices, no customer list and no invoices. Before you hand someone the app, use See their view on their row to check what they see. See Roles and permissions.
  • Their day on a phone. Today shows each stop with the address, the crew notes and the next step. See Crew's My Day.
  • Hours and pay. Crew clock in on their phone, and you set each person's pay on Pay > Pay setup. Chalk records pay, but it does not run payroll, send money or work out payroll taxes. See Clock in, track hours and fix timesheets and Set up crew pay.

For a new hire's first days, print the crew onboarding checklist.

Sources