Crew and hiring

From solo to a crew: when and how to hire

The numbers that say you're ready to hire, what changes when you stop doing every job yourself, and the order to add people: helper, lead, office help.

Adrian GluchowskiOwner of Superior Stain Solutions, builder of ChalkLast reviewed 8 min read

On this page

Doing everything yourself works until it stops working. You turn away jobs. You work Saturdays. You quote at night. You get sick and the money stops. At some point, someone says "you should hire somebody," and you think, "with what money?"

This guide gives you a way to tell when you are ready, how to check that you can afford it, what changes in your own job when you stop doing every job, and the order to add people. For the legal side of the first hire (employee or 1099, paperwork, workers' comp), read Hiring your first helper, which this guide does not repeat.

Signs you're ready

You do not need all of these. Three or four means it is time to take it seriously.

  • You are turning work away, or telling people "four weeks out," and losing some of them.
  • You work more than 50 hours a week and the extra hours are the production.
  • Estimates and paperwork happen at night, because the days are full.
  • Your jobs are two-person jobs (ladders, big decks, heavy equipment) and you pay a friend cash or lose the day.
  • Your calendar is full for a month ahead for at least two months in a row.
  • Callbacks and mistakes come from rushing.
  • Your quotes close at a good rate, so more capacity means more money, not just more work.
  • You have a cushion: at least two months of costs in the bank.

And signs you are not ready:

  • You are not sure of your prices. See the hourly rate guide.
  • Your calendar is full only in spring.
  • You cannot say what a job cost you. See job costing.
  • You are hoping a helper will bring in the work. A helper does the work. You still bring it in.

The numbers: can you afford a helper?

The question is simple: does the extra work the helper unlocks pay for their cost, with room to spare?

Step 1: what a helper really costs

Use a loaded cost: wages plus employer taxes, unemployment, workers' comp and the hours that are not billable. Our hiring guide works through a seasonal helper at $20 an hour for 13 weeks of 40 hours (520 hours). The total is $12,131.60. Your numbers will differ: your state's unemployment rate and your workers' comp class change the answer.

Step 2: how much extra revenue you need

Not every dollar of revenue is yours. Some goes to materials, fuel, disposal and supplies. If those are 25% of revenue, only 75 cents of each new dollar is left to pay for the helper.

Extra revenue needed = helper cost / (1 - job costs)
                     = $12,131.60 / 0.75
                     = $16,175.47 over the 13 weeks
                     = $1,244.27 a week

Over a full year at a $47,817.70 loaded cost (the $22 an hour employee in the hourly rate guide):

Extra revenue needed = $47,817.70 / 0.75 = $63,756.93 a year
                     over 46 working weeks = $1,386.02 a week
                     at $450 an average job = 3.1 extra jobs a week

Step 3: do you have those jobs?

This is the real test. Count them honestly:

  • Leads you turned away or delayed in the last 90 days, times the average job value.
  • Quotes that went cold because you could not start for weeks.
  • Repeat customers you could book if you had capacity.
  • Work you decline because it takes two people.

If the last three months show about $20,000 of work you lost for lack of capacity, and your seasonal helper needs $16,175, the math works with a margin. If you only lost $4,000, wait, or start smaller.

Step 4: start smaller if the answer is "maybe"

  • A part-time helper for 15 to 20 hours a week during the peak.
  • A seasonal hire with a clear end date. See hiring seasonal crew.
  • A trial month with a paid working interview first.
  • A real subcontractor for specific work, not a helper in disguise. See the sub rules in the hiring guide.

Check the numbers with the break-even calculator (add the helper's cost to your fixed costs) and the crew capacity calculator (try a second crew, or a shorter job time with two people on it).

What changes for you

When you hire, your job changes before your income does. You are no longer only a painter, a cleaner or a mower. You are a person who has to:

  • Plan the day for two instead of one, so nobody waits.
  • Explain, check and fix. Teaching takes time, and the first month will be slower than working alone.
  • Take responsibility for someone's income. If you cannot get them hours, you are the reason.
  • Do payroll, or pay someone to.
  • Sell more, because the extra capacity needs jobs to fill it.
  • Let go of "my way." The crew will do it well, not exactly like you.

Expect the first 30 to 60 days to feel worse. You are slower, the helper is slower, and you are paying someone. If nothing is better by month three, something is wrong, and it is usually one of three things: not enough work, not enough training, or the wrong person.

Who to hire first

The order matters. A common path for service trades:

  1. A helper (or a second crew member). Handles the labor: loading, prep, cleanup, lifting. Lets you finish jobs faster and take on two-person jobs. Start here.
  2. A lead or tech. Once the helper is trained, a more skilled person runs a second crew or a job on their own. See making someone a crew lead.
  3. Office help. When the paperwork, phones and scheduling eat your evenings, hire part-time office help. It is often the best second hire, because it gives back the hours you are worth most for.
  4. A salesperson or estimator. When selling is your bottleneck, not production.

A different order can be right for you. If estimating and paperwork are what hold you back, an office hire first can add more capacity than a helper. Ask where your own hours go: if 15 of your 50 hours are admin, taking 10 of those off your plate is as good as hiring a production helper, and it costs less.

Systems before people

A new hire in a business with no systems is a recipe for chaos. Before the first hire, put a few things in writing:

You do not need all of this to start. You do need enough that your helper can ask "where do I look?" and get an answer that is not you.

Your first office help

When to add them: when your evenings go to quotes, invoices, scheduling and phone calls, and you would pay a fair rate to hand them off.

Part-time first. Ten to 15 hours a week handles a lot for a crew of three or four. The typical tasks:

  • Answer calls and texts, and book estimates.
  • Send quotes and follow up. See how to follow up on estimates.
  • Schedule and move jobs.
  • Send invoices and reminders.
  • Collect payments and record them.
  • Enter hours and prepare pay.

What about a virtual assistant? A remote assistant or an answering service can take calls, book estimates and send reminders. It can be a cheaper start than an in-house hire, and it works when your needs are mostly phones and follow-up. The tradeoffs: they do not know the work or your area as well, you need clear scripts, and you have to give them access to your tools, so choose people you trust and limit what they can see. Anyone who works for you the way an employee does can be an employee in the eyes of the law, so read the classification section in Hiring your first helper.

Family and spouses. Many small businesses have a spouse doing the books. It works well when there are clear roles, written pay, and time off. See your accountant about how to treat it.

Mistakes

  • Hiring before you have the work. Payroll starts on day one and revenue takes weeks.
  • Hiring the first person who says yes. Take two weeks and use a working interview.
  • Calling them 1099 to save money. See the hiring guide.
  • No training plan. You will be the training plan, at your most expensive hour.
  • Not raising prices. If your price does not cover a crew, hiring just makes you busier and poorer. See how to raise your prices.
  • Keeping all the sales and all the production. You need to hand one off.
  • Forgetting yourself. Pay yourself first, from a number you worked out.
  • Hiring in a panic. See hiring seasonal crew.

How Chalk helps

This part is about our software. Skip it if you only want the hiring advice.

  • Seats and roles. Each person after the owner is a seat at $14 a month, or $140 a year on a yearly plan. Invite someone under Settings > Team, and choose their role. A helper starts as Field crew, who sees only the visits they are on, with no prices. An office person usually fits the Office role. See Add your team and Roles and permissions.
  • A time clock. Crew clock in and out on their phone, and you check and fix the week on Pay > Hours. See Clock in, track hours and fix timesheets.
  • See what a hire will see. See their view on a person's row shows Chalk exactly as they will see it, with changes blocked.
  • Job profit. Reports shows what each finished job sold for, what it cost and the profit, using crew time and receipts, so you can see whether the extra hands paid off. See Reports.

The free trial includes you and up to 2 teammates at no charge, so a new hire can try it with you. Chalk records pay but does not run payroll or file taxes. See Plans and billing.

Sources

  • The seasonal helper cost ($12,131.60) and the $22 an hour loaded cost ($47,817.70) come from Hiring your first helper and the hourly rate guide. The unemployment and comp rates in those examples are made up, so use your own.
  • The 25% job cost, the $450 job and the $20,000 of lost work are examples. Use your own.