Most contractors say they lose estimates "on price." Sometimes that's true. Often it's a guess, because they never wrote down why. A job that went quiet looks the same as a job lost to a cheaper bid, so everything gets filed under "price" and the real leak never gets fixed.
This guide is the diagnosis: how to work out your close rate the right way (it's more than one number), how to record a reason for every loss, the five reasons that account for most losses, and how to decide which to fix first, with an example. The cadence and the scripts for chasing a quiet quote are in How to follow up on estimates.
Count it right: close rate by count and by dollars
"Close rate" can mean several things. Pick one definition, write it down and stay with it, or your numbers will drift.
There are three that are worth knowing:
- Close rate (count): quotes won divided by quotes sent.
- Win rate (decided only): quotes won divided by quotes that got a yes or a no. Quotes still waiting are left out.
- Close rate (dollars): dollars won divided by dollars quoted.
Example. The numbers are made up. In the last 90 days you sent 30 quotes:
| Outcome | Quotes | Dollars |
|---|---|---|
| Won | 12 | $38,400 |
| Lost, expired or ignored | 14 | $61,600 |
| Still out | 4 | $12,000 |
| Total sent | 30 | $112,000 |
Close rate by count = 12 / 30 = 40.0%
Win rate (decided) = 12 / (12 + 14) = 46.2%
Close rate by dollars = 38,400 / 112,000 = 34.3%
Dollar win rate (decided) = 38,400 / (38,400 + 61,600) = 38.4%
Notice the gap. You win 40% of your quotes by count but only about 34% of the dollars. That tells you something the single number hides: you're winning smaller jobs and losing bigger ones. Your average win is $3,200 ($38,400 / 12), and your average loss is $4,400 ($61,600 / 14). The question is not "how do I close more?" It is "what is going wrong on the big quotes?"
Three rules that keep it honest:
- Leave out quotes that are too young. A quote sent yesterday has not had time to be answered. Count quotes that are old enough to have had an answer, such as those sent at least 30 days ago, or past their expiry date.
- Don't mix leads and quotes. "Leads to won" includes people you never quoted. "Quotes to won" is about your selling. Both are useful. They answer different questions.
- Count by source. A 70% rate on referrals and a 20% rate on web leads average out to a number that describes neither. If you pay for leads, this is also how you find out whether a site earns its keep: see Are lead sites worth it?
To see what your close rate means for next year's leads, plug it into the revenue goal calculator.
What's "good" (and why there's no honest single number)
You will find numbers online: "a good close rate is 30%," or 40%, or 60%. I did not find a source for a single number I'd trust, and the ones I saw don't say what trade, what lead source or how they counted. A cleaner who quotes a standard price from a form wins a different share than a stain contractor who quotes $8,000 jobs after a site visit.
What does hold up:
- A very high rate can mean you're too cheap. If you win almost everything you quote, test a price increase. See How to raise your prices.
- A very low rate often means you're quoting the wrong people or answering late, more often than you're too expensive.
- The useful comparison is you against you. Your rate this quarter against last quarter. Your referrals against your web leads. Jobs under $1,500 against jobs over $5,000. Your replies within an hour against replies the next day.
Write your rate down once a month. A trend is worth more than a benchmark.
Record a reason for every loss
You can't fix what you don't name. For every quote that doesn't close, write down one reason, within a day or two while you remember. Use a short list so you can add them up later:
| Reason | What it means |
|---|---|
| Price | They told you it was too high, or they took a cheaper bid. |
| Timing | They want it later, or the season ended. |
| Went with a competitor | They picked someone else for reasons other than price (or you don't know). |
| No response | They never answered after the quote. |
| Out of area / not a fit | You shouldn't have quoted it. |
| Other | Something you want to remember. |
The best way to get a real reason is to ask. After your last follow-up, send a short message:
Hi Dana, I'm closing out your deck estimate. If you have 10 seconds, it helps me a lot to know why. Was it the price, the timing, or you went with someone else? Any answer is fine.
Many won't reply. Some will, and what they say is gold. If you don't know, write "No response," not "Price."
The five usual reasons
Almost every loss fits one of these. Each has a different fix.
1. You were too slow
The lead went to someone who answered first, or you sent the quote a week after the visit.
- How to tell: the loss notes say "went with a competitor" or "no response," and the customer's first message to you was hours before your first reply.
- Fix: answer within minutes, and send the quote the same day. See Speed to lead.
2. No follow-up
You sent the quote and waited. The customer got busy and forgot.
- How to tell: lots of "no response" losses, and quotes that sat with no touch after the first message.
- Fix: a follow-up plan with set days. See How to follow up on estimates.
3. Wrong customer
They were never going to buy: a price shopper, a tenant without the landlord's approval, someone outside your area, or a person "just curious."
- How to tell: "price" losses where the customer never engaged with the scope, "out of area," and quotes you wrote with no real conversation.
- Fix: ask a few questions before you drive out and say your minimum. See How to book more estimates. Quoting fewer of the wrong people raises your close rate without any change in selling.
4. Price, or how the price looked
Sometimes the number really is higher than the market will pay for what you offer. Often it's how the number was presented: no explanation of the work, no options, a page of line items and no conversation.
- How to tell: the customer says "too high," and especially if other bids were for less work.
- Fix: present in person and show what's included (see How to present an estimate). Offer options, such as good, better and best. Learn the replies in What to say when a customer says your price is too high. Don't lower prices until you've ruled out the reasons above.
5. Trust or fit
They liked someone else more: more reviews, a better website, photos of the work, a friendlier tone, a recommendation from a friend.
- How to tell: "went with a competitor," often with a neighbor's name attached. Your reviews and photos are thinner than theirs.
- Fix: reviews, photos of finished jobs on the quote, and a referral routine. See How to get more Google reviews.
Fix the biggest leak first
Add up your losses by reason, in dollars. The biggest number is where to start, even if it isn't the most fun to fix.
Example, continued. Your 14 lost quotes ($61,600) break down like this:
| Reason | Quotes | Dollars | Share of lost dollars |
|---|---|---|---|
| No response | 6 | $24,000 | 39% |
| Price | 4 | $21,000 | 34% |
| Went with a competitor | 2 | $9,000 | 15% |
| Timing | 1 | $5,000 | 8% |
| Out of area | 1 | $2,600 | 4% |
| Total | 14 | $61,600 | 100% |
The first instinct is to cut prices. But the biggest leak is "no response": six quotes, $24,000, where the customer simply stopped answering. That is a follow-up problem, not a price problem.
What fixing it is worth: say a better follow-up wins back a quarter of that.
Recovered sales = 24,000 x 0.25 = 6,000
Gross profit at 40% = 6,000 x 0.40 = 2,400
That is $2,400 of extra gross profit in 90 days with no price cut. Compare it with the price losses. To win back the $21,000 of "price" quotes, you would have to cut your prices, and a 10% cut costs a quarter of your profit on every job you already win, at a 40% margin (see the table in What to say when a customer says your price is too high).
Do the cheap, certain fix first. Check again in 90 days.
When a quote counts as lost
Your numbers are only as good as the line between "still out" and "lost." Pick a rule and keep it:
- A quote is lost when its expiry date passes, or when your last follow-up has had a week with no answer, whichever comes first. How many touches to send before that, and what to say, is in How to follow up on estimates.
- Record the reason the day you close it, while you remember. "No response" is a real reason, and the most useful one to count.
- Timing losses get a reminder, not a lost tag and nothing else. "Call Dana in March about the deck." Count them apart from the rest, because some come back.
- If they come back after expiry, re-price it and count it as a new quote. Reviving the old one makes last quarter's numbers look better than they were.
A lost quote you keep calling is not a pipeline. It is clutter, and it hides your real close rate.
How Chalk helps
This part is about our software. Skip it if you only want the sales advice.
- Mark a lead lost with a reason. On the Funnel, Not interested (in Log a call) asks why, and the reasons are Price, Timing, Went with competitor, No response, Out of area and Other. Under Move it, Lost asks why too. See Work your leads on the Funnel.
- What happens to estimates. In Reports, Overview has a Sales and pipeline card for the period you pick: the estimates that went out, won and lost, and the close rate (won out of sent), with their value before tax. A quote you archive without a yes counts as lost, and a won quote you archive stays won.
- Win rate by person and by source. The same card splits it by salesperson and by lead source, and Marketing shows lead to won by lead source.
- Quotes that nobody answered. Auto-archive stale quotes quietly archives unanswered quotes after 60 days unless you change it. It is off until you turn it on. Quote follow-ups, which are also off until you add them, run on a ladder of days. See Automatic reminders, follow-ups and review requests.
- What Chalk does not do. It does not work out the reason for a loss, and it has no close rate by dollars as a single number. The reason comes from you.
FAQ
What is a good close rate for contractors?
There is no single number we trust. The figures online rarely say what trade, what lead source or how they counted. Compare yourself against yourself instead, quarter to quarter and lead source to lead source.
What is the difference between close rate and win rate?
Close rate is quotes won divided by all quotes sent. Win rate counts only quotes that got a yes or a no, so quotes still waiting are left out. In the example on this page they come to 40% and 46.2%.
Why do customers ghost after an estimate?
Common reasons are that they got busy, are still comparing bids, or the price surprised them and they did not want to say so. Many "no response" losses are really a follow-up gap, which is cheaper to fix than price.
Should I lower my prices if I am losing estimates?
Not until you have ruled out slow replies, no follow-up and quoting the wrong customers. Add up your losses by reason in dollars first. A 10% price cut costs a quarter of your profit on every job you already win, at a 40% margin.
How do I find out why I lost a quote?
Ask once, after your last follow-up: "Was it the price, the timing, or you went with someone else? Any answer is fine." If they do not answer, record "No response", not "Price".
Sources
- The definitions, the worked example and the reason list are the author's working method, not a study. The example numbers are made up; use your own.
- I did not cite an industry close rate on purpose. The numbers I found did not say how they were counted.