It happens to everyone who works long enough. A mower throws a rock through a window. A cleaner drops a vase. A pressure washer etches a pane of glass or strips paint you did not mean to touch. Overspray lands on a car. A drip dries on a stone step.
What you do in the next hour matters more than the damage. This guide gives you a first-hour checklist, helps you decide between fixing it yourself and calling your insurer, and explains a gap in many liability policies that surprises small contractors: the "your work" and "care, custody or control" exclusions.
The first hour: stop, photograph, tell them
- Stop and make it safe. Turn off the machine. Shut off water if something is leaking. Keep people and pets away from broken glass or chemicals. If anyone is hurt, call 911 first, because this guide is about property.
- Don't touch the evidence. Don't sweep up, wipe, or try a quick fix. A photo of the damage as it happened is worth ten after you "cleaned it up."
- Photograph it. One wide shot that shows where it is. One medium shot that shows it in place. One close shot with a coin or tape measure for scale. Photograph the area around it too, because that shows what was already there. Take a short video if it helps.
- Write down what happened, right now, in your own words: the date, the time, who was there, what was being done, and what you saw. Don't guess about causes. "At about 10:40 the mower threw a stone toward the front window. The window cracked at the lower left."
- Tell the customer yourself, in person if you can. Don't let them find it. A script:
Dana, I need to tell you something. While we were mowing, a stone hit your front window and cracked it. I'm sorry. I've taken photos so we have it on record. I'm going to call my insurance company now, and I'll follow up with you today with what happens next.
- Don't argue about cause or blame, and don't promise a payment yet. "I'll make sure it's taken care of" is fine. "I'll pay for it myself" or "it's covered" is not, until you know.
- Tell your crew not to talk about it on social media, and to send you their own photos and notes.
Why the last point on promises matters is in the next section. If the customer is upset, the scripts in difficult customers help you keep it calm.
Fix it yourself or file a claim?
There is no right answer. It depends on the size of the damage, your deductible, your claims history and your policy. Here is how to think about it.
Fix it yourself when the repair is smaller than your deductible, the customer agrees, and your agent has told you that not filing will not hurt your coverage if the customer later asks for more. Most policies want to hear about anything that could turn into a claim, even if you plan to pay. A small paint touch-up, a replaced sprinkler head or a replaced plant is the usual case. It keeps a claim off your record.
Call your insurer when the damage is large, the customer is angry, the cause is unclear, or anyone mentions a lawyer. Also call if the damage is the kind your policy might not cover and you want to know before you spend money.
The catch: voluntary payments. Most general liability policies say, in the section on what you must do after an occurrence, that you may not voluntarily make a payment, take on an obligation or spend money, other than for first aid, except at your own cost, without the insurer's consent. In the standard form this sits among the insured's duties after an occurrence, claim or suit. See the International Risk Management Institute (IRMI)'s definition of the prohibition of voluntary payments provision. The point of the clause is that the insurer gets to investigate and take part in settling a claim. If you pay first and ask later, you may be on your own.
Policies also require you to tell the insurer promptly. Look for "Duties in the event of occurrence, offense, claim or suit" in your policy and read the time limit.
A middle path that works for many owners: call your agent before you promise anything, even if you plan to pay. Ask, "If I fix this myself for about $400, does it count as a claim?" Your agent can tell you what to do without a claim record, and it is a free call.
How a general liability claim works
In outline, for the claim most small contractors would file:
- You report it to your agent or carrier, with the date, place, what happened and your photos. Many carriers take a claim by phone or online.
- An adjuster is assigned. They may call you, the customer or both, and ask for photos, notes and your contract.
- They decide whether it is covered. They check the policy: is it "property damage" caused by an "occurrence," and does an exclusion apply?
- If it is covered, they pay for the repair, usually to the customer or the repair company, after your deductible. If it is not covered, they send a letter explaining which part of the policy applies.
- Your premium may change at renewal, depending on the claim and your carrier.
Cooperate, answer in writing, keep copies, and don't discuss fault with the customer in ways that conflict with your report.
The care, custody or control gap
Here is the part that surprises people. A general liability policy is built to cover damage you cause to other people's property. But the standard form carves out several kinds of damage. Three of them matter to a small contractor:
- Care, custody or control. The form excludes property damage to personal property that is in your care, custody or control. In plain words: things the customer handed to you or that you took charge of, like a rug you took away to clean, a car you were washing, a boat you were detailing. See the explainer by Amwins (July 2024).
- The part you are working on. The form excludes damage to "that particular part of real property" on which you or your subcontractors are performing operations, if the damage arises from those operations. Think of the siding you are staining, the roof section you are working on.
- Faulty work. The form excludes the particular part of any property that must be restored, repaired or replaced because your work was incorrectly performed on it.
Put together, a common pattern in a pressure washing or cleaning job looks like this:
| What happened | Likely covered? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Your mower throws a rock and breaks a neighbor's car window | Usually yes, as property damage to someone else's property | Not the thing you were working on |
| Your washer etches the driveway you were hired to clean | Often not | It is the part you were working on, and "your work" exclusions often apply |
| You wash a customer's patio furniture and it is damaged | Often not under the standard form | Care, custody or control, unless you bought coverage for it |
| Overspray from your stain gets on the neighbor's fence or a car | Usually yes | Damage to other property |
| A cleaner breaks a customer's vase in the house | Depends on the form and endorsements | It is the customer's property in a place you were working, but this is where policies differ |
The Power Washers of North America (PWNA) explains this for washing contractors in a March 2026 article. It says a carrier advertising "customer property protection" is often offering only the limited care, custody or control coverage, and that a contractor who mainly washes buildings and concrete may get little from it, since the main risk is damage to the surface being worked on. It suggests asking about a "your work" buy-back or property damage extension endorsement, which some carriers offer with a sublimit. The article ends with a plug for an insurance agency, so treat any sublimit numbers as one broker's view.
Sources disagree on the edges. Courts read "that particular part" differently, and endorsements change everything. That is why the answer for your business has to come from your own policy and your own agent.
What to ask your agent this week
Send these in an email so the answers are in writing:
Hi [agent], I run a [lawn / cleaning / pressure washing / painting] business. Please tell me, in writing, how my policy responds to the following.
- If my crew breaks something inside a customer's home, like a vase or a window, is that covered?
- If we damage the surface we were hired to clean, paint or stain (for example, etching a driveway or glass), is that covered, or does a "your work" exclusion apply?
- Does my policy have a care, custody or control exclusion, and what exactly does it exclude for the kind of work we do?
- Is there an endorsement or a separate policy that fills the gap, and what does it cost? What are the sublimit and the deductible?
- Do subcontractors or helpers change any of this?
- How soon must I report an incident, and what must I not do (for example, make payments) before I report?
- What is my deductible, and does a small claim raise my renewal?
Keep the reply with your policy. Ask again each renewal.
Common damage by trade, and how to prevent it
| Trade | What goes wrong | How to prevent it |
|---|---|---|
| Pressure washing | Etched concrete or glass; water behind siding or into vents; stripped paint; damaged window seals; plants burned | Test a hidden spot first. Use the lowest pressure that works. Keep a safe distance and angle from windows, doors and vents. Pre-wet and rinse plants. Match your method to the surface. |
| Soft washing and roof cleaning | Chemical on plants, metal staining, slipping and falls | Cover or wet plants first. Rinse thoroughly. Use correct mix ratios. Follow the label. See roof cleaning. |
| Staining and painting | Overspray; drips on stone, carpet or glass; stain on a car | Mask windows, fixtures and floors. Move or cover cars. Watch the wind. Check drip trays. |
| Lawn care | Thrown stones; scalped lawns; hit sprinkler heads; trimmer damage to trees | Walk the yard first and mark heads. Clear stones and toys. Use deflectors. Keep distance from cars and windows. |
| Cleaning | Breakage; scratches; wrong product on stone or wood; water damage | Ask what is fragile. Move breakables first, or leave them. Test products on a hidden spot. Never use acid on natural stone. |
| Window cleaning | Scratched glass; damaged screens, blinds or sills; drips on floors | Check glass for coatings and hard water first. Use clean tools. Lay towels. |
| Handyman | Holes in the wrong place; hidden pipes or wires; floor and wall damage | Check what is behind a wall before cutting. Protect floors. |
Before photos are your best defense
The first question in any damage claim is "was it already like that?" A set of before photos answers it. A cracked pane, a stained step, a worn shingle: if you photographed it at the start, you can prove it was there. See job site photos for a shot list.
For work with real risk (old glass, brittle siding, a stone patio), also use a short written acknowledgment that tells the customer about existing conditions, which our expectations and waiver form shows how to do. A waiver does not remove your duty to take care, but it sets honest expectations.
How Chalk helps
This part is about our software. Skip it if you only want the advice.
- Photos on the job. The crew's Photo button on a visit files pictures on the job, tagged before, during or after by timing. Before they clock in, they count as before photos. See Crew's My Day.
- Photos for the office only. On the finish sheet, Add a photo for the office keeps pictures such as damage or a leak off the customer's page. Photos added with Photo and before and after photos can show on the customer's own page, so use the office-only option for anything the customer should not see yet. See Photos and gallery.
- Notes and history. Add a note or Log a call on a job's Activity card, and the job's History card shows who did what and when. See Office history.
- A checklist item. You can add a required Photo item such as "Before photos of windows and surfaces" to a checklist, so the visit cannot be marked done on the crew's finish sheet without it. See Run a job from approval to invoice.
Chalk does not file insurance claims or track them. It keeps the evidence in one place so you can hand it to your agent.
Sources
- Amwins, CGL exclusions common to construction-related claims (July 15, 2024), on exclusions j(4), j(5) and j(6) of the standard commercial general liability form.
- Power Washers of North America, General liability insurance: your work vs. care, custody and control coverage (March 31, 2026).
- International Risk Management Institute (IRMI), Prohibition of voluntary payments provision.
- Our licenses and insurance guide covers the main types of cover. Your actual policy form and your agent decide how it applies to you.