If every question on every job comes to you, you do not have a crew. You have helpers. The first step to getting your evenings back is a lead: one person on the truck who owns the job when you are not there.
Promoting the wrong person, or promoting the right person with no plan, goes badly. The new lead is in over their head, the crew resents it, and you end up on the phone anyway. This guide covers what a lead actually owns, how to choose one, how to pay them, how the day starts and ends, and what they can decide alone.
What a lead owns
Write the job in one page. A lead is not "the best worker." A lead is a person who is responsible for four things on the days they are in charge.
- Safety. The crew works safely, uses the gear, and nobody is hurt. They can stop the job.
- Quality. The work matches the scope and the standard. They do the final walkthrough with the customer.
- Time and schedule. The crew arrives on time, the job stays on pace, the day ends on time, and the office knows early when it will not.
- The customer. They are the face on site: hello, a clear update, a calm answer, a clean exit.
And the supporting duties:
- Opens the job: reads the work order, checks materials and gear, briefs the crew.
- Assigns the work to the people on site.
- Trains the newer people on the job. See training a new crew member.
- Takes the before and after photos and the crew's notes.
- Handles the handoff to the office at the end of the day (below).
- Reports problems early, not at the end.
A good job description reads like a checklist, not an adjective. "Keeps the crew safe, brings the job in inside the hours on the work order, and has the customer sign off at the walkthrough" is a job description. "Leads by example" is not.
Picking the right person
The best painter is often the wrong lead. A lead needs skill, but they also need to be reliable, calm with people and able to communicate.
Look for:
- Shows up on time, every time, and has done so for months.
- Cares about the standard. They notice the missed spot without being told.
- Others listen to them. Watch who the newer crew ask for help.
- They tell you bad news early. A person who hides problems is a bad lead, however good their work.
- Can write a clear text. The handoff depends on it.
- Wants it. Some people do not want the extra responsibility, and that is fine. Ask.
- Is safe. No exceptions.
Test before you promote. Name them "lead for the week" on one or two easy jobs, with a clear list of what you expect, then review. A short trial protects you both. If it does not work, they go back to being a tech with no shame.
And be ready for the tradeoffs. If you promote one person, someone else may feel passed over. Say why, in terms of the skills on your ladder.
Lead pay: rate, bonus or share
There are three common ways. They can be combined.
| Plan | How it works | Good for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| A higher hourly rate | The lead earns a premium, such as $3 an hour above the tech rate | Simple, predictable | It does not reward results |
| A bonus for results | A small share of the job when it finishes within the budgeted hours and passes a walkthrough with no callback | Pulls the lead toward your goals | Needs a clear, fair formula and honest hour budgets |
| A share of profit | A percent of what the job made after costs | Leads who think like owners | A bad job pays nothing extra, which can sting. See the profit share guide. |
A worked example
A lead is paid $22 an hour, plus a result bonus of 1.5% of the job revenue for each job that finishes inside its budgeted hours and passes the walkthrough with no callback.
In one week, the lead's crew finishes 4 jobs worth $2,400 each. Three of them hit the mark. The lead works 44 hours.
Straight-time pay = 44 hours x $22 = $968.00
Bonus = 3 jobs x $2,400 x 1.5% = $108.00
Regular rate = ($968 + $108) / 44 = $24.45
Overtime premium = 0.5 x $24.45 x 4 hours = $48.91
Total for the week = $968 + $108 + $48.91 = $1,124.91
The bonus is part of the regular rate, because it is promised in advance by a formula, so it raises the overtime pay too. Skipping that step is one of the most common pay mistakes. The full explanation, and the day-rate and piece-rate versions, are in day rate vs hourly crew pay. Leads leave for the same reasons anyone does. See how to keep good crew members.
Salary does not make a lead exempt
Owners sometimes promote someone to "lead" and put them on a salary, thinking that ends overtime. It does not. The Department of Labor says job titles do not decide exempt status. A worker generally has to meet both a salary test and a duties test, and manual laborers, like carpenters and painters, are not exempt regardless of pay. A working lead who spends most of their time doing the physical work is almost always still owed overtime. See the DOL's Fact Sheet 17A. The salary level has changed over the years, so check the current one at dol.gov. Pay a lead hourly with overtime unless a payroll professional tells you otherwise.
The morning and evening handoff
A lead's most important habit is a short, regular handoff with the office. It replaces most of the calls.
Morning (5 minutes, before they leave the shop or at the first stop):
- Read the work order together: scope, colors, exclusions, access and gate codes.
- Confirm the crew and the gear. Anyone missing?
- Name the risks: weather, a dog, a tight driveway, a fragile window.
- State the plan and the time you expect to finish.
Evening (5 minutes, by text):
A text in a set format. For example:
Job: Price, 14 Oak St. Done: front and side washed, deck prepped. Not done: back deck, rain at 2. Photos: 14 before, 12 after. Problems: loose rail at the steps, customer knows. Change: none. Tomorrow: finish back deck, start stain 10 AM. Hours: 3 people x 8.
Five lines. Done, not done, problems, changes, tomorrow. It takes two minutes to write and saves the call at 8 PM.
A weekly 15 minutes on Friday: what went well, what broke, what you need, who needs training.
What they decide, and what they call about
Without limits, a lead either calls about everything or decides everything. Write it down.
| The lead decides alone | The lead calls first |
|---|---|
| The order of tasks on site | Anything that changes the price |
| Who does which task | Anything that changes the scope |
| Whether to stop for safety or weather | A customer who is angry or threatening |
| Small fixes at no cost, such as touch-ups | Damage to property |
| A schedule change of under an hour | Moving the job to another day |
| Answering the customer's questions about the work | A new request over a set dollar amount (see below) |
| Sending the crew home for heat or lightning | Any injury, other than first aid |
A dollar limit for extras. Many shops let a lead say yes on site to a small add-on, such as up to $150 or 5% of the job, whichever is less, and call for anything bigger. Pick numbers you can live with. The rules:
- The lead writes it down: what, where, how much.
- The customer says yes in writing, even a text.
- The lead tells the office that day.
Change orders on site
A change on site is where money gets lost. The customer says "while you're here," the lead says "sure," and you pay for it.
- Give the lead a script. "I can do that. Let me get you a price, and we'll add it once you say yes."
- Give them a form. A short change order, even a text template, with the work, the price and a yes. See change order form for contractors.
- Make "no" easy. "If it is outside the work order, call me" is an order. Back them up when they do.
- Review each week. If extras are being done for free, find out why.
Growing them into management
A lead who does well can keep growing. Some paths:
- Estimator or salesperson. A lead who knows the work and talks well can learn to price.
- Production manager. Runs more than one crew, plans the schedule and checks quality.
- Trainer. Runs onboarding for new hires.
- Partner or owner of a branch. For a few, in the long run.
Ask them what they want. Some want more money, some want more time, and some want to stay on the tools. Each is fine.
How Chalk helps
This part is about our software. Skip it if you only want the advice on leads.
- There is no built-in Crew lead role. Chalk's roles are Owner, Admin, Staff, Sales, Estimator, Office, Field crew, Bookkeeper and Custom. A lead is usually a Custom role that you name yourself under Settings > Team, in What each role can do. Custom starts like Staff, so check what it can see, and switch off what a lead should not have. The schedule can be Everyone's or Their own. Use See their view on the person's row to check exactly what they will see before you hand it over. See Roles and permissions.
- Pay types. On Pay > Pay setup, a person can be paid by the hour, by the day or by the job, with sales pay and commission on top. On a job, Pay someone from this job can add a flat amount, a percent of the job or a percent of the profit. See Set up crew pay.
- The handoff. The lead's Today screen shows each stop, the notes for the crew, the checklist and the finish sheet, with After photos and a Note for the office. See Crew's My Day.
- Changing the work. When a quote becomes a job, the quote is sealed. Change the work and price on the job, and send the customer a fresh yes. See Run a job from approval to invoice and Change a quote after it is sent.
Chalk does not work out a bonus for you, or hold a limit on what a lead can approve. Keep that rule in your SOP and on the work order.
The lead's own day on the phone, step by step, is in a crew lead's day in Chalk.
Sources
- U.S. Department of Labor, Wage and Hour Division, Fact Sheet 17A: Exemption for executive, administrative, professional, computer and outside sales employees, which says job titles do not decide exempt status and that manual laborers are not exempt regardless of pay.
- U.S. Department of Labor, Overtime pay and 29 CFR 778.208 on bonuses in the regular rate, and 29 CFR 778.111 and 778.112 on piece rates and day rates. See day rate vs hourly crew pay.
- The pay, the bonus formula, the job values and the $150 limit are examples.